This book drones on. I thought it was me not paying enough attention, but I actually got lost with what was going on it was so boring. This is the same writer that wrote 2001: A Space Odyssey & had I thought about it, that movie was a story that could have been told in about 10 minutes, but was hours long. The book is very disconnected, the character development is poor & after I restarted it to try and get into it, I finally gave up after the 4th chapter.
Had some interesting parts but jumped around a lot. Not one person except for the aliens lasted more than a few chapters. Not because of action or battles but because massive amount of time has past.
Considering that it was written in the '50's, it is quite good. But compared to some of the writing on even a mediocre sci fi television show, it just doesn't hold up. I understand that Clarke was a pioneer and I respect that, but the story doesn't hold up all that well.
Maybe it has a place in SF history, but it has not aged well at all. Summerer tackles the narration well, though the story is not one that I would call decent SF. It didn't leave me feeling fulfilled, nor excited.
Too many questions went unanswered. Why? Who? and Why? again. If you want to complete your SF library, or adore Clarke, then you may as well get this one, because there are better audio books on offer out there if you're looking for something meaty.
If it wasn't a Clarke, I'd have said "meh"
I know a lot of fans will protest any criticism of one of the greats, but I prefer my science fiction not to wander into the realm of fantasy and religion, which this one does. When the paranormal and God (or any unknowable and all powerful entity) is the driving force of the plot, it is fantasy and religion in my opinion. So I feel a bit mislead by the fact that this masquerades as sci fi. That is not to say that it won't have a great deal of appeal, and if you like fantasy and religion, it is well written and well done. However, if you do not like those things, and are hoping for a science fiction novel, though superficially this seems like one, by the end it has completely transformed into a fantasy story about religion. I suppose the warning should have been the introduction by Robert J Sawyer, who is endlessly preoccupied with religion, but I don't think it is clear enough
I could not even make it through the first hour of this book, it was labeled as a classic and on sale, once again I see, you get what you pay for, except I did not even the sale price out of this one, my husband did tough it out and listen to it but he said it was horrible and the biggest waste of time do not be suckered into purchasing this book, even if it is on sale
Clarke is one of the giants, and this work was acclaimed as one of his best, which is why I was eager to listen. In short, two things bothered me: first the authors' political biases dominated the story, and second the disappointing outcome, which was not quite "he woke up and it was all a dream," but close. That's not to say that it had no redeeming qualities, and if you share his political views or don't care about those things, you'll enjoy Childhood's End.
I could not get through this book. The characters were boring. I do want to know how it ends, but I just couldn't stay with it to get there.
This book reminds me of "Spin" in that there's and alien presence and the purpose of said presence is unknown. This story, however, if fully contained in one book. Its revelation, at the story's end, is stunning and left me heavy of heart, but it took me to a place, emotionally, that I seldom go. This was an awesome ride and isn't for the faint of heart.
The revelation that the human species wouldn't evolve without ending, while the overlords could not evolve but could continue as- is. I can't decide which of the two species should be pitied more.
This is not a book you'll forget which is annoying since it's greatness lies in its one main idea but I didn't enjoy the execution of the story. For instance I've already forgotten the lead characters names and the subplots seemed like time fillers. There were too few characters to support a novel. It would have been a better novelette. I would encourage others to read it though if they are interested in early science fiction. That's why I read it. The reader did a good performance and his voice works well on the 2x setting on my player!