McCormick's reading of the story is mostly competent. Her voice is pleasant to listen to, not monotonous, and she gives the different characters their own voices. There are a few odd readings of lines - one or two mispronunciations of words or misunderstandings of how a sentence is meant to be read.
For example, there's a line that runs something like 'by the way Peeta says this I know blah blah....' (as ''from the manner in which Peeta say this, I know...').
McCormak reads it as if there's a comma there: 'by the way, Peeta says this, I know...' (as in, 'incidentially, Peeta says this, I know...') rendering the sentence nonsensical.
There's few examples of careless slips like this, things which should have been picked up on in the recording.
But overall a good read.
I listened to this is just a couple of sittings while I got on with work. Though the first third drags rather, I was engaged enough throughout to keep me listening fairly attentively.
In some ways 'Catching Fire' is an improvement on 'The Hunger Games': secondary characters are more fleshed out, and the world is explored satisfactorily. It doesn't have the narrative momentum of the first book though and it is only really in returning to the same territory as The Hunger Games that collins seems on firmer ground.
Frustratingly, though the first half of the book largely consists of Katniss exploring her feelings and presenting in more depth to us the environment of District 12, many of the most interesting questions of character and world, on which the story rests, are never really addressed.
Collins hasn't got much feel for character, or world building, or narrative drive - but somehow, surprisingly, the books manage to surpass these shortcomings to remain intriguing, enjoyable and memorable - even quite powerful.
This was a good book, but frustrating since I suspected most of what would happen 15 minutes or more ahead of time and the waiting for it actually to occur was infuriating. In the end, however, it is the execution that matters and the book was well written in that respect. If you enjoyed the first book, you should definitely listen to this one.
These books are great when driving alone and waiting in doctors' offices, etc.
First part just makes you thirsty for the second part.
Hunger Games. Part of the series I'm addicted to.
I was listening while typing at work and what a rememberence when I gasped out loud when Katniss and Peeta were watching Haymitch's old game and had to walk and hold his intenstines in at the same time. How can anyone forget?
Does this remind of of Three Dog Nights' song
I bought this because my wife had read the series about a year ago and she loved all three books. As a sequel, I thought it was pretty much as great as the first, and I think the reader, Carolyn McCormick, again did a great job. Well done. I'm looking forward to the final book, especially since I've read reviews that both loved it and didn't like it...
I loved the entire series, and even better the narrator was amazing, the only problem is this was the first book I purchased on Audible and now I keep trying to find not only a story that is as wonderful and detailed as this one, but also one that has an amazing narrator, worth buying and you will want to listen to it over an over!
Author of romance and women's fiction, violinist and horse trainer.
Exciting, romantic, triumphant.
It's hard not to love Peeta. He reminds me of my husband. He's so loving and honest, says what he feels and doesn't make excuses.
I've not heard this reader before. She does a fine job.
I wanted to know what would happen in the next book. As an author myself, I know how hard it is to keep pace and interest through a series. I was interested from a writer's point of view what she would do with the last book in this trilogy. You will have to read it to find out because I won't tell.
Definitely worth the time. Easier to listen to this series than to read as a book. I read the last one and now wish I had listened to it instead. Because of the first person point of view throughout the series, the stream of consciousness style is a bit hard to read, but as an audio book, it works well.
she made me fell like i was there
yes but i didn't because it is 11+ hours but if I could of I would of
Honostly I feel silly listening to a book if I can read it (I buy these things for road trips and any commute in the car). However with this book in particular I find myself listening to it outside of my car. I could not stop listening. I wanted to find out what was going to happen next! It was the times I caught myself infront of my computer listening instead of doing my work that I felt silly and really wished I had the book. Nonetheless the audio version of this book is very addictive.
katnip of course
made my heart beat a little faster
great job by Carolyn McCormick. Even better job by the author.
I personally believe the narrator can make or break an audiobook. This book proves my point. I purchased "Catching Fire" from Audible after reading a Kindle version of "The Hunger Games", and I wound up deleting my audio recording and purchasing "Catching Fire" on Kindle because I couldn't stand the narration. Carolyn McCormick may be an excellent narrator and her style may work perfectly in other readings. However, her voice just doesn't fit my impression of a 17-year-old girl. Ms. McCormick sounds too adult and I couldn't get past that inconsistency while I listened. I note that other young adult novels (the "Twilight" series, for example) use narrators that at least sound the age of the characters, even if they're not the same age. A better narrator would have made a good sequel in a fascinating trilogy great.
If you've read the first one, you will most likely read this one and, as I am doing right now, download the third one as soon as this one finishes. Amazing continuation of The Hunger Games. I loved the first one so much, I was afraid this one would disappoint. Not only did it hold up to the greatness of the first, it was even better.
The one thing that irritated me was in the beginning, Collins felt the need to re-state things we had learned in the first book as if for a reader who may not have read The Hunger Games or it had been so long they might need some reminding. A small grievance though as I listened to this one in less than 3 days. It would have been less if I hadn't had to work!
Another non-stop, action packed novel that will keep you riveted. Again, it was written for a less mature audience but I didn't miss the stuff that would have been added if it were written for my own age group. I can do without the sex, swearing and detailed gore.
Katniss has lost some of her naivet?? but not enough to make her unlikable. We get a little more character development in Catching Fire than Hunger Games but it's still mostly an action novel especially once it gets going.
I have to go now since Mocking Jay has finished downloading and I must go listen!