I would probably not try another book by Murakami. This one had a certain weird appeal but I found it long, wordy, and slow. I will certainly avoid anything narrated by Rupert Degas, unless I'm sure that there are no female characters, because he adopts an unconvincing falsetto when voicing females. They all sound exactly alike - like a man trying and failing to sound like a woman. And much of the book - at least as far as I got - consists of the main character (a man) repeating long stories told to him by female characters. I found it very distracting, then infuriating, and eventually stopped listening.
I haven't tried any others.
I don't know. He would have been okay except for the strange quirk of putting on a fake high voice for female characters. Good narrators (David Aaron Baker, Andrew Sachs etc.) don't do that.
You end this book a little disoriented. Quite the back and forth between characters and story lines. I think this is a book meant to enjoy good writing, character development and excellent narration. As far as the overall plot, I just don't know what to say. I did look forward to getting into the car in the morning to continue the story, a good sign for me. I would caution a person that this is not the traditional book with a straight forward plot. More an artistic work by a very talented writer.
mind bending philosophy
Mr Honda yelling.
Kumiko, because she sounds interesting.
I hate the character of Mai Kasahara. She's so annoying.
I recognize that is a work of great literary merit, but here's the thing - I rely on my audiobooks to keep me awake and entertained on my commute or when I'm walking the dog in the wee hours of the morning. So in retrospect, maybe downloading such a character-driven book was setting myself up for failure, but I just couldn't finish the blankedy-blank thing. I found myself so frustrated with the main character and all of his "Bartleby the Scrivener"-type ways. I also found myself wanting to punch him in the face for the amount of time he spent wondering if his wife were on her period. I hate to leave books unfinished and tried to stick it out. But in the end, the thought of continuing on with this one just made me start avoiding my iPod, so I had to call it quits.
I'd have to agree with other reviewers who noted that the narrator's female voices are creeptastic. But honestly, so are most of the female characters in this book, so it's kind of a wash.
I guess I'd recommend thinking really carefully about what you want out of an audiobook before downloading this one. No question that it's wonderfully written, and (for the most part) well narrated, but it just wasn't what I wanted to be listening to.
This is an "off beat commentary" of a young japanese man who has a rich inner life. It is fantastical but it captures the mundane thoughts we all have much of the time. It is brilliant in presenting metaphors in different forms and in weaving the occult with the real. I read the entire first section and part of the second before becoming tired of the story. There is really no story - just the ongoing commentary of the lived life of the main character. I will pick the book up later, to read more, as the mood strikes.
The story might be compared with a David Lynch movie. A household cat vanishes and as the protagonist sets out to find it, the normalcy of his life dissipates into a compelling, dreamlike narrative.
The one big minus for me, is the reader doing female voices.
While it is amazing that a guy can present a repertoire of female characters. In the end, its still a guy doing a variation of a high pitched, emotional voice and -for me- it still sounds goofy and distracting.
For a guy to do a female voice he pretty much has to make it somewhat of a stereotype. For example, a high pitched teenage girl voice. These stereotypical depictions detract from the characters' complexity and makes them sound like the cartoon network.
I would prefer for the production did not exert the effort to make feminine voices and let the content of their words carry the book forward.
I would still recommend this audiobook and -from reading the comments- I realize that my opinion about the narration is not universal.
To start, the performance is absolutely excellent, but the voice the narrator gave to some of the minor characters was grating and unpleasant to listen to. Compared to the whole of the 26 hour duration, these bouts of audial discomfort were few and far between.
The story itself is engaging but very choppy--a first-person narration where the protagonist often listens to others talk about their lives in the first-person for entire chapters on end. Nothing progresses linearly. The core narrator will revert into flash-backs, and the tales he hears from others are often broken into nonsequential parts. Additionally, characters who seem important will often fall away from the story without warning. All of these reasons are why I gave the story a 4 instead of a 5.
With all that said, however, I would still give the overall piece as it is a 5 out of 5 stars. Often the plot will meander from the protagonist's life to focus on the back stories of relatively minor characters, but it is never uninteresting. Even the smallest of characters seems to have something significant worth sharing. It will sometimes make the main plot feel slow, but to borrow an analogy, the experience is more akin to taking the scenic route than getting stuck in traffic waiting for something to happen.
This is the first piece I have ever "read" by the author, and I fully intend to pick up more of his work.
This book will invade your brain and stay there. It's one of the strangest books I have read and definitely one of the strangest I've listened to.
Murakami is amazing, but if this is your first book of his to read, I would not recommend it. It's dense, meandering and surreal. Other books such as "Kafka on the Shore" and "Dance, Dance, Dance" are good starting points.
The audio I found to be ok. I felt the performer spoke too slow and I had to increase the speed. If one speaks too slowly when discussing dreams, it's bound to put someone to sleep. After I increased the speed on the audio, the book worked for me.
I've been listening to audio books of novels I'd previously read for a while now, and up next on my list was one of my favourite Murakami pieces. When I read this novel it was an immediate stand out, and it is so finely crafted and beautifully told. The story is full of wonder and intrigue, with just a little darkness and science fiction.
Unfortunately this audio book version is a huge let down. The performance by the narrator is actually pretty good until you get to the female characters. His female voices are so annoying to listen to and so over the top and thoroughly dumb sounding. This is especially bad when the characters are incredibly strong.
I usually give narrators a good chance to sell their interpretation to me, but after a few hours I just couldn't take it any more and unfortunately had to give up this listening. As I said; terribly disappointed.
What a shame it's not the same narrator as for Kafka on the Shore or even Hardboiled Wonderland and The End of the World.
I've listened to over 70 audio books in the past few years and this is the only the second one I completely gave up on and only the first that was due to the narrator.