At first I found the storyline to be bland and the characters blander...the narrative seemed flat...but I did like the book better toward the second half as it did pick up. I do believe the character development needed improvement but the unique tale kept me interested. This is book one of three, I listened to the other two after this and the author does improve and grow, which I appreciated hearing and witnessing!
Should have listened to Untateve! Gotta remember that!
Two dimensional characters who think/talk like they have a room temperature IQ and plot a blind man could see a mile away. Not only did I not care about the characters, I found myself looking forward to their deaths. However, for this book to be worth what I paid for it would be that ALL the characters die horrible deaths. No such luck.
Geez Louis! Books like these should offer a refund for being so bad or at least an anti-nausea potient
Oh well, back to listening to Outlander for the umpteenth time. How much longer can it take Gabaldon to write another book about Jamie ???
I thought this was a fantastic book- full of adventure, excitment, and danger with a touch of magic and romance. I finished listening to it last night and I'm downloading the sequal right now!
I would highly recommend this to any woman who has a warrior adventurer hidden inside her. The prose is somewhat stumbling at times (a breeze smelling as fresh as "expensive perfume'??) but the story is satsifying and engaging. I downloaded the 2nd book in the middle of this one, knowing I would be wanting it right away.
I couldn't endure any more. I gave up after chapter 17. I've listened to recorded books for over 15 years and this is the first one I couldn't finish. "Amateur" is the word that comes to mind. Amateur writing and amateur reading. Someone below mentioned Frank Muller in the same sentance as this reader. In her dreams!
This read is by far superior to most that I have read! Its characters are soundly created and the story flows nicely. There are many unexpected twists and turns in this story making it difficult to stop listening to once you start. I really enjoyed this book. Don't miss the sequel to Poison Study, Magic Study as it is equally absorbing! You will not be dissapointed with this one.
This was one of the best stories I've listened to yet! Initially, I skipped over this book, not believing I would enjoy aa "fantasy" type story. It was a lack of new material that caused me to try this one and I am so glad I did. I've listened to both Poison Study and Magic Study several times already and have gotten my two young teens into it as well. Audio books are the best use of an Ipod in my opinion. My only complaint is that I now have to wait nearly a year for Fire Study to come out. Great job by the author and the reader!