I really liked this story. It was a bit improbable, but then I read all sorts of improbable and impossible stories, so it was pretty much right up my alley. I really liked the narrator. She didn't try to make everyone's voice different; she narrated it - told the story as one would do in one's head if they were reading it. I really, really appreciate this. So the performance was first-rate, plus she has such a wonderful lilt! The story was quite intriguing and kept me guessing until the end. A good mystery.
This is a very engaging book. I read it out of order. I learned Into the Woods is the first book. It reads well as a stand alone as well. It's engaging and kept me guessing all the way through for a number of reasons.
The story is about a cop who used to work under cover and goes under cover again after a murder has taken place and the victim has a remarkable likeness to our main character.
Our main character is likable and due to issues from a previous investigation is dealing with a large amount of stress and was not ready to go under cover. You go through her attachment to her new housemates and essentially goes native. A large part of the drama is how she deals with the attachments and her assignment.
Heather O'Neill has a fantastic narrator and does the accents really well.
Life is great!
This book ranks in my top few favorite listens so far. Tana French is an artist that deserves high praise. The imagination required to dream up this very different murder mystery is second to none. The characters are portrayed with depth and forethought. I never guessed what was next and had a time putting this story down while never wanting it to end! The narration by Heather O'Neill was excellent and I look forward to hearing from her more.
Yes-I loved Heather O'Neill's performance of Cassie!
Cassies relationships with everyone at the house and distinguishing reality with her job-great performance!
The accent and raw emotion in her voice.
Not laugh or cry but I could not stop listening to this book! I stayed up very late-love all of Tana French's novels.
Bring Rob and Cassie back together!!!!
i like to read. i like to listen.
i think tana french is such a fantastic writer. she really gets into the characters minds, thoughts, insecurities...and writes a thrilling and engrossing story to go along with those characters.
Heather O'Neill was the perfect voice for Cassie. i particularly loved cassie's character in 'In The Woods'...so this story focusing on her made me really happy. she was a great narrator. for some reason she seemed more reliable than Rob Ryan was in In The Woods. maybe i wanted to believe her more? maybe the point of the first novel was to be 'tricked' by the characters surrounding the narrator, but this one was to more be in love with them?
whatever it is, i love how tana french writes. this book in particular could be made into a really great movie. an undercover agent taking the place of her dopelganger to find out who her murderer was...i mean, it's got hollywood written all over it.
i kind of figured out who the murderer was pretty quickly, but it didn't matter at all...the writing is so good it does keep you guessing, and second guessing who you think did it....and the final wrap up in cassie's life was extremely satisfying.
can't wait to read Frank's story next!
JUST KIDS by Patti Smith.
her great accents make it more real.
the premise of the story IS impossible. the more you know about people the less you can go along with the premise. you have to suspend disbelief from the beginning and that ruins everything. i won't say more because I don't want to spoil it for those more naive than I. how this book ever got past the first editorial meeting i'll never know.
the author can write well and i enjoyed the parts where the group of 5 are living in and working on the old mansion in the country. but that's incidental to the main story line.
this book asks for a large investment of your time. if you have lived quite a bit of your life already, I'm afraid you won't enjoy this book because it will feel like a waste of your time.
Enjoying one good listen after the next!
This is my third Tana French book and I continue to be amazed at the way she weaves the plot and characters of her great stories so expertly. This book features Cassie with Frank and Sam playing secondary roles to her detective work. That required a female narrator who did a respectable if not perfect job.
This plot is especially intriguing, based on the idea that everyone has an identical double somewhere in the world. What if your double was murdered? What if your now dead double was using an identity you had used years ago on an undercover case? What kind of mind games would this perpetuate? How in the world would you solve the crime?
Tana French's mind works in wondrous ways, using delightful characters and plot twists that keep you guessing and wanting more. In short, this was an amazing listen! I was totally engrossed after only 10 minutes and could barely make myself take a break. If I could have, I would have listened to it one sitting.
If you like Irish accents and great murder mysteries, you can't go wrong with this pick.
Maybe, not likely for Tana. No on the narrator.
The premise is stretched to snapping. The story is so slow. You don't get involved in the story let alone involved with the characters. It does not draw you in or make you care about what's next. She should read Jeannine Frost and Deborah Harkness for how to move along, pace, get your reader wanting more. Deborah's book is long but it keeps you wanting more and to know what is going to happen next to the characters. You care.
Tavia Gilbert would be perfect or Jennifer Ikeda.
None are bad there just benign.
Yes, this was a great story with a great twist. It caught my attention from the first chapter and I could not wait to get to the end to see what happens.
Yes. I was so caught up in Cassie being Lexie that I felt for her and all the decisions she made, I probably would have made the same ones.
No I have not.
I would not call it an extreme reaction, but I did laugh and cry.
Great book! I highly recommend it to anyone who likes a good murder mystery and wants a fresh way to tell the story.
Yes, because the book is read with a variety of Irish inflections that enhance the characters and story. It is a delight to listen to.
The plot is intriguing, not your usual mystery fare. But it is the character development that really is really interesting. Much of what happens in the book goes on in the mind of the narrator..
The Irish accent is interpreted differently with each character. She is a wonderful actress.