loved it. was very absorbed by the story although struggled through the first 5 chapters
"Good sequel (or subsiquential) and Narrator first class but..."
...the songs throughout are absolutely awful! I get that as part of the unabridged book that they should be there, but I'd rather the lyrics were read out - then again I skipped them all and didn't miss them... so 5* for Lorelei's narration and 0* for the god awful singer.
"Remove those awful hymns!"
I rated 1 star for the performance as I could not stand the hymns. The narrator was excellent. Just get rid of the sung hymns and get her to read them instead, the audiobook will be greatly improved.
"Bad production choices"
I was a little worried about how good a follow up this was going to be and, unfortunately I was largely correct. Too much time is spent early on in the narrative where if there is overlap, it is subtle. Once the stories of the first and second book start to converge, it gets a bit rushed.
Also, who the hell decided to actually have songs in the audiobook? They're tedious enough in print, never mind having your audiobook interrupted by them! The narration was just below average. Not terrible but not great either.
Basically the story picked up toward the last third of the book, otherwise I would definitely be returning it. I may still do.
I've been a long term fan of Margaret Atwood, some books I've appreciated more than others. This book and the preceding "Oryx and Krake" plus "Madadam" the last in the trilogy are so impressive I have listened to them twice now. They are so well crafted, so immersive, she has created such a completely believable world in all it's intricacies with such complex interesting characters. I feel as if when I listen to them I am wandering in that place again, noticing new things, more details, and more connections to our world now (sadly). I recommend this to anyone, her story is relevant to us all and such an exciting read.
I had read the book earlier so I knew what this was about, so it was easy for me to follow the story. I also loved the narration, Lorelei King is very good in making distinction between different characters and also brining an extra dimension to their portrayal. I know some prefer monotone reading, but I don't, it is a matter of preference.
The story told through Ren and Toby unfolds gently, the picture is built piece by piece, and the world that is depicted is frighteningly plausible. Atwood's style is unique and not everyone likes it, but I am always mesmerized.
There are some comments claiming that The Year of the Flood is simply a rehash of Oryx and Crake, but I think they are missing the point. They are two sides of the same coin, a story told in two (or rather three) points of view, and while they both stand alone (I read The year of the Flood before Oryx and Crake) together they form a full story that is more than sum of its parts.
And the hymns... I thought they were hilarious! I think anyone who has ever had to endure Kum-ba-yahs will appreciate how perfectly awfully they were rendered!
Just keep an open mind!
Not as good as Oryx and Crake but Atwoods insights and observations are as brilliant and insightful as ever.
wow. Margaret at wood is a revelation. can't wait to listen to more. bye now
"Great story, great reader, terrible songs"
Why did they do the songs in such a cheesy awful way. Tarnishes an other wise great audio book. Love the trilogy
"Musical element utterly ruined this for me"
The story is fabulous and King's narration is faultless but the twee singing of the hymns is jarring and ruinous.