I bought the trilogy after the repeated recommendation of a friend. However, I only listened to the first when I realized I would not be listening to anymore. --
In the entire first half of the book (8 hours) there is only one action scene, there is no real significant character dialogue, and I wasn't invested in the characters. I fought myself to finish. --
This book attempts to stress the Science in Science Fiction, but the science is so dated that it gave the story a shelf-life. This is not always the case with older scifi, but it is definitely what happened here, the story was too weak to support the setting, and the book was obviously written to express the setting. --
The reader lacked any real emotion in his delivery, but does a good job making you aware who is talking with all but the female characters. The recording would have benefited from some editing. There are too many times I hear the reader make large swallows (I actually believe he was taking a drink) and other issues that made the production feel sloppy. --
I reserve 1 star ratings for works that I cannot bring myself to finish, so this is the lowest rating I could give.
If you enjoy AC Clarke, Brim will thrill you. One of the greatest true science fiction writers I have read in the last 25 years.
His awards through the years are ssoooo well deserved. The more you are aquainted with real science, the more you will love Brim's works!
The unusual nature of the subject material, delivered in a way that made it seem like complete sense. Characters were compelling and complex
Wilson has to account for a variety of species and personality types and does a fantastic job. He stays away from caricature and delivers both aliens and humans perfectly.
didnt finish. struggled to get half way. was a wate of mone th for me.
presentation was ok. bu th half wag through still didnt have a grip on the plot. obviously not my ad ort of sci fi
The setup and premise of this series of books is pretty good But this particular book was often pretty boring. It had some good part at the end but overall it was hard to get through. Glad I listened to it at 1.25X. I heard the next book in the series is much better. Probably be a while until I actually read it though - still not recovered from this books slow pacing.
I have read and listened to this story many times over the years and each time I do it seems so smart, original and new. So many interesting plots, sub-plots; characters are developed enough to keep you longer for more and more.
The sign of a great audio book is that you sit in the car listening for several minutes
after you park it. By that definition, this book is mediocre. I always parked the car and got out immediately. I did listen to it, waiting patiently for it to introduce something thought provoking. But that's all I did, wait. It never happened. And I did not give up on it either. It was acceptable enough that I listened to it in one take.
Generally, I like David Brin's work. So Sundiver seemed like one of those must reads.
The main character was basically the "smartest man on earth" plus baggage who just happens to come from a family of smart people who are all well beyond over achievers.
The story was less sci-fi and more whodunit with aliens sprinkled in. The sci-fi parts were hand wavy and not in a good way. This was more like a 50's gumshoe novel with a beautiful smart dame, except that this dame is completely self sufficient.
The story just never came together for me.
The performance was VERY good. Kudos Mr. Wilson. Various characters from different species. Your work made the characters come to life as best they could.
I'd recommend this book to anyone who likes hard scifi, with credible aliens and strong plots. David Brin doesn't hold your hand or explain his jokes--he treats you as an intelligent reader, capable of figuring out by yourself the humor of a situation. A rare thing in SF.
There are elements of Sundiver (and of the whold Uplift trilogy) that remind me of Asimov's Foundation series, in the sense that a "band of curious and investigative humans" are set against a backdrop of complacency and intellectual conformism. Otherwise, it's hard to compare Brin's books to anyone else's--few authors are as lucidly optimistic about the human race and its future.
The story is riveting and the premise intriguing: there's a spaceship, and it dives into the sun, which humans suspect is haunted. I may not have a specific favorite scene, but let's not kid around, here--this by itself is a fascinating and gripping premise.
Overall, while I may not have cried or laughed while listening to this, the whole "universe" and backdrop kept me interested from beginning to end. The whole status of the human race as (potentially) a self-evolved race (rather than being uplifted) is a very clever concept and made me feel oddly proud of my race and its achievements. This is something very rare in modern SF, where human-bashing is the norm. Brin stands against that and offers a refreshing view of ourselves.