There is much to recommend this book. I found the story surrounding China and the situation Chinese immigrants found themselves in most compelling. Being from the Los Angeles area, I liked all the details about life in downtown. I loved the exploration of the relationship of the sisters.
All that being said, the ending was not satisfying. In fact, the last part of the book seemed to loose energy. Worth a listen, certainly. I give it a 4 because it made me think of many things.
Well written book.., I loved the story.., the relationship between the 2 sisters, the cultural shocks between USA and China.., the story really moves you.., although at the end of the book seems the writer just let the reader an unfinished feeling
This is a very special book. I learned so much about China in the 1900's and the plight of women, and how simple yet difficult life was then. Its also very Poignant in how it portrays the relationship between the two sisters who lose all the comforts as well as their parents and family home and run to California to suffer more hardship and disgrace. While battling their own insecurities, fears and jealousies, they lose everything but the love for each other. SIGH! This is a beautiful gift for your sister or best friend. Like most of Lisa See's novels, this is a classic.
I thought this book was mostly well-written, and the narrator was quite good. It's a grim story, with little lightness. I felt that the author ran out of story at the end, and just left things hanging. Sometimes this is done to set up for a sequel, but I'm not interested enough to want to read a sequel.
Lately it seems that more often than not, I purchase books and can't finish them. Either poor narration or the story just isn't compelling. That certainly was not the case with this treasure. Right from the start, the story is fascinating and I was shocked to learn that a non-Chinese woman wrote the story as it sounds so very authentic. The narration is spot on, and she does a great job with a variety of different characters. I'll purchase her other books based on my experience with this one
Like others have said before, the end of this book was not a real end, I agree and would've like a bit more closure. BUT, don't let this stop you from buying it! You will enjoy it. It's been a while since I enjoy an audiobook so much (and I get bored easily), it is easy to follow and full of layers. Good book!
i was so excited to read the newest book by lisa see, since i have fond memories of her other novels. but this novel just did not do it for me. perhaps, it was the melodramatic tone of the narrator's voice...i don't know...but this book was a mild dissapointment. i could tell that this was very well researched, and i did find the bits about "china city" in los angeles fascinating. but overall, i did not look forward to listening to this tale. and, sorry to say...the ending was quite lame.
As the audio reader raced through all the wild and unfortunate events of the sisters...I went along with sympathy and hope for their well-being. This book left me thinking and wondering.
I found this book to be incredibly enjoyable and did not want to see it end. Although other reviewers seemed disappointed with the ending, I liked the ending because it left the door open for a sequel ( I hope). And even if a sequel never comes to be, I still liked the ending because it was neither syrupy sweet nor awful and depressing. I know I will listen again.