Absolutely good listen. Phil Gigante is a wonderful narrator. I was totally immersed in the story and voice. I am getting the rest of the series as soon as possible.
Tell us about yourself!
I do not make a decision on whether to read or not a book based on decisions because I do understand that people have different perceptions and tastes. However, I do like to read reviews on every book I read, then I've decided to start writing them up as well lol
It's my first Moning book and I loved it! Of course, I have a weakness about "highlands" hee hee... but she wrote a good story! Strong-willed, poweful, extremely manly and dominant hero, pretty normal in this kind of genre. And the heroine, really beautiful, but having not had good look in her love life, has been hurt before and now fights against that stereotype of man. I loved the way she developed the story and everything around them.
I've read some reviews bringing to attention the fact that the time and culture accuracy are off. Well....speaking for myself, I am not that anal, after all, this is fictional fantasy,, it's literature... which means, anything is possible and permittable. Who really cares if in that time, they had coffee, tea, or potatoes for that matter.... the heroine is addicted to coffee (like me), NOT ALE..... *spoiler* :) He bargains with her... morning kisses for her morning coffee LOL if she is anything like me, I'm not gonna pay the tool for ALE but I'd definitely do it for coffee :)
Another topic of quite a few bad reviews I've read was the narrator. I have nothing to complain about him. I personally think Mr. Gigante did a great job both with the males and females voices. I like that he doesn't try to hard to make the accent; he doesn't try to hard to high pitch his voice for a female voice, to me it sounds natural; and last but not least, his intonation. I like that he gasps, laugh, chuckle, grawl, etc, etc..... He doesn't narrate those actions being done, but does them!
I hope my review have helped :)
No, I would not listen to this again, because the narration/production was poor. As I don't have time to read actual books usually, I don't regret the credit, but recommend a more traditional reading experience for others. I've never been bothered enough to offer the caution. I will acknowledge that it's bearable, and I still couldn't stop listening for desire to hear the tale... I may listen to the next in the series despite the narration issue, but it won't be without reservation.
The narrator, whom I see is unfortunately responsible for the rest of this series, which I am starting to really enjoy, does a fantastic job regarding the basic telling of the story, but fails in all other respects. The men sometimes sound like one another making it difficult to distinguish who is speaking at times. That said, the main male voice was superbly strong and appealing. His portrayal of the women was distractingly poor (impossible to forget this was just a man reading a script - more thought on the narrator than the story at those times - it sounded as if he was mocking women when reading their lines, though I know that was not the intent).
Expected a more realistic Scottish brogue. Adrienne's fake female accent moved in and out between standard American, New Orleans/Deep South, and the same bad attempt at a Scottish accent.
Occasionally, the production involved whispers from the fairies... Had to replay more loudly and more slowly to make out the words. Frustrating!
The ambience was lovely. There was intense satisfaction when the characters were finally honest and communicating with each other (as well as themselves). For all of his flaws (being DENSE primarily), I had sympathy for the male lead, and was happy when he was.
Possibly. This series only. Necessity only. Wonderful male voice. Exception to my answer if female narrates alongside him.
This was a fun book I wish I had "read" traditionally, but too much focused on introspective thoughts and feelings that would not translate to film well, so I cannot answer this...
I TRULY enjoyed the story.
When it began, I was itching to turn it off. The storyline was corny (fairies whisking a woman away from the 20th century to torment a man in the past. She's chosen, because she "hates beautiful men," because one hurt her. The motive against the guy in the past is jealousy, because he unwittingly pleased the fairy queen... Yeah, OK... That plus bad narration equalled BAD!
As the story progressed, I never developed sympathy for the woman, and I found the writing a little immature, BUT, I DID start to become attached to the characters overall. I wanted to know how they would resolve their issues. I was frustrated by the lack of communication that caused pointless problems. I was overjoyed when they healed some of their emotional wounds. I could relate to their hopes.
The descriptions were vivid, and very good. Charming. For all the many flaws, I stayed up till daybreak listening till the end. I can't imagine how much more I'd have enjoyed it in paperback form or if they'd tied up a few loose ends better.
I think I'm ambivalent. I did enjoy it enough to be unable to "put it down," but I was also disappointed. Don't expect too much, and you'll be OK. I read a review that compared this to "Outlander," which was what I expected. As a comparison, it's a total insult to that series. By itself, for what it is... It's a fun read...
What a delightfully sensitive hero. Hawk is perfect with his tough outer shell and amazing inner vulnerability. Does Ms. Moning know anyone like this in real life? Because, I would beg an introduction. :-)
This is a wonderful start to a great historical series. I am looking forward to the rest. Narrators voice for the men is chilling but the women's voices are a little irritating.
This is a spellbinding book that makes me want to keep driving I listen to it on my way to work and back and I love the highlander I just wish there were still men like this in todays world. Phil Gigante is a great voice for all the characters and makes the story come to life. Thanks both to Karen Phil and Audible for making a lonley woman dream of a better life out there. I helps to take my mind off of the problems I face they take me to another time and place where women are cherished and treated like a woman should be treated. Not where they are taken for granted and used up and then discarded like last weeks garbage to make room for another.
Mom, cupcake froster at local gourmet shop, and avid listener to books while doing said frosting or housework. True audiobook addict!
After listening to this book I fell in love with the series and devoured each one! I'm a big fan of historical fiction and especially anything dealing with the Irish or Scots.
Her plots are predictable, but honestly, I listen to this fluff because it is far from reality and it's entertaining. It never left me bored, that's for sure! And it made me want to know more about the characters and find out what would happen to them next.
Phil Gigante is an awesome reader! He has an amazing Scottish lilt - honestly I think his voice could melt butter LOL
Love the first of this series. I especially enjoyed the narrator. He captures the essences of the book and makes you feels as though you are there. He carries an incrediable sexy voice and I am amazed that such a sexy male voice can also carry off a female. I can't wait to hear the rest of the series and hope he is the narrator for all.
One of the best audio books I have listened to so far. I am looking forward to listening and buying other books written by this author. The audio kept you listening and wanting more.
I have just finished the last of the latest Highlander books, and I must say that KMM is an amazing story teller. I enjoy the science, the history, the Myths, and especially the romance! Never thought of myself as a Romance fan, but Karen has got me HOOKED! I strongly recomend ALL 7 and then, the Fae Series!