Mother of 3, grandmother of 6, retired nurse and substance abuse counselor. Thrilled to have the time to read or listen to books again.
I'm at a loss as to how this writer could ever be compared to Diana Gabaldon. There is no comparison, I'm at a complete loss as to how this book ever got published. It is juvenile and extremely frustrating to listen to as the narrator is very annoying.
The story line is quite pathetic especially the "love" story it tries portray as there is nothing in it that has any ring of truth to it. It's a work of fiction to the extreme but in every book you want to feel that the love story the author touches upon is at the very least fesible somewhere. I found everything in this book to be unbelievabe on every level. Sorry I wasted my money.
I love to read! With kids, that hobby is impossible...enter Audible...problem solved. Chores that I dread are now quiet time for this Mommy!!!
I have read a few of the other reviews and almost did not purchase this book because of them. I found Phil Gigante's voice perfect for this series! It is true that it takes a few miuntes to get used to him in the female voice...but he IS a man. I find the same to be true when I listen to Anne Flosnik, or Rosalyn Landor...they are women so it takes a minute to get used to their male voices. All three are excellent narrators.
As for the story, I thought it was sweet, funny at times, and very tortured. The loves seens were steamy and descriptive. If that is not what you are looking for in a Romance, don't read it! I read this genre for tortured romance that drags out a bit. I also do NOT read romance for the character depth. Don't get me wrong, the character has to be believeable, which these two are, but I read the classics for character depth. I like a hero that is perfect for his heroine, damaged and male. The heroine needs to be troubled and not let go of her past, or vice versa. If they resolved the problems in the first three chapters, why would the rest of the book need to be written?
I highly reccommed this book to anyone who loves historical romance FICTION :)
I am married with a teenage son and run my own business. As I am visually impaired, audio books are my life.
As soon as I started listening to this I immediately thought this is so corny, predictable and very cliche, however I did get caught up in the story and ended up enjoying it. It's not as sappy as I thought it would be. It's easy to listen to and the narration was good
Yes, the audio version gave me the time and imagination to absorb the story and the speakers voice enriched the story as it progressed.The speaker couldn't do the women's voices with perfection, however, with the speaker being a male it could hardly be expected. Still, the acting and annuncation was outstanding.
Kathleeen Woodiwess's, 'A Rose In the Winter' The auther spent plenty of time developing the sub charectors and the pov was excellent just like one of my favorite writers Kathleen Woodiwess. The book left me wanting more.
The inflection of passion to the dialog that is missed by merely reading the book.
I didn't want the story to end and felt a little sad to say good bye to the charectors.
Really good read...I am so tired of reading a romance written with the sole pov of the hero is lust and the story centers around the couples sex life. Even though this story had it's far share of sex scenes it didn't make me gag and say, 'Enough Already'. The author did a good job of capturing my interest in the Scottish scenery, strong dialog,and clever plot satisfied my opinion that this was indeed a good story.
AKA The Geeky Blogger
Bought on Audible
Audio Rating: 3.5
What I Loved: Adrienne was such a perfect woman for a man like the Handsome Hawk. I laughed so many times while listening to this book, pretty sure the people around me thought I was a bit crazy. It really was just such a fantastic combination of romance and humor. Really the best part is that this is a Paranormal romance but the two leads are perfectly human. It really was a great twist on the genre.
What I Liked: How the Fey played into the story and getting a glimpse into the couple that started the Guardians that we see in the Fever series. I actually think reading that series first added a little extra oomph to this book!
Audio Specific Review: Narrated by Phil Gigante (who was the male voice in the last 2 of the Fever Series) and he did an excellent job on Hawk's and the rest of the male voices. It took awhile to get use to the voice that he used for Adrienne though, it was a little to high pitched for my taste. Still a very fun listen and Phil has a knack for pacing (not to fast, not to slow)!
Why I gave it a 3.75: The story was very strong and the audio was pretty good also. It was fun, sweet, and full of great Historical moments that I love!
Who I would recommend this too: Historical and Paranormal Romance readers. This romance has a bit of both!
I loved this book and all the others that followed. You wont be disappointed by any of the Highlander series. I dispoisted that there are only 4 books in this collection. I really hope there will be more Highlander series soon.
This is a spellbinding book that makes me want to keep driving I listen to it on my way to work and back and I love the highlander I just wish there were still men like this in todays world. Phil Gigante is a great voice for all the characters and makes the story come to life. Thanks both to Karen Phil and Audible for making a lonley woman dream of a better life out there. I helps to take my mind off of the problems I face they take me to another time and place where women are cherished and treated like a woman should be treated. Not where they are taken for granted and used up and then discarded like last weeks garbage to make room for another.
If you are interested in this genre, then read The Outlander series by Diana G. These books were a cheap thrill with poor writing. Not impressed at all.
I had high hopes for this book as it is the first in a series and I'm dying to be hooked on new series, but this book feel real short. I found the story was lacking depth and the vocie of the narrator did little to bring to life a slow, dull story. I was expecting more.