If it weren't for the fact that I lived and worked in Cambridge during the time in which this novel is set, I would have only given the book two stars. For me, the story's locale brought back many personal memories, and so for that reason, I enjoyed the book more than I would have otherwise. At times it seemed that I was listening to a story being read in the children's room at the public library. The reader often seems to drop syllables from certain words, but that is really just a minor defect. My main criticism of the story is the forced way in which the protagonist's name is used. It seems a device, a distraction, and has really very little to do with the tale being told, as if Ms. Lahiri was writing for a topic assigned in a creative writing class. Perhaps, with a bit of editing, she could have removed the intrusion of Nikolai Gogol into her story completely.
The author relates the biographies and immigrant experiences of four main characters, centering for the most part on Gogol Ganguli, born at Mount Auburn Hospital in Cambridge, the son of Ashima and Ashoke Ganguli recent Bengali immigrants from Calcutta, and one other second generation Indian, Moushumi Mazoomdar. Her descriptions are vivid, almost mathematically precise. She succeeds in conveying the emotional lives of her characters. Since I very much enjoy novels by Indian authors of late, I felt I did gain some insight and perspective on their lives and culture. Nevertheless, the essentially quotidian nature of the story is not enough to make this great literature. It barely rises to the level of good soap opera.
Immigration lawyer in Kansas City. I like Character driven dramas, fantasy (monsters, magic and witches oh my!) and coming of age stories. Favs include: The Book Thief, The Game of Throne series, Harry Potter Series, Dresden Files, Nightside series, anything by Neil Gaimen, 100 Years of Solitude.
I liked this book but didn't love it. I enjoyed the characters and the story. I liked how the author really showed that the main character was constantly ill at ease with himself and his life and his identy.
There's no doubt that this is a well-written and well put together novel. It builds slowly and tells the story of an ordinary man, struggling with the disparate parts of his background and his environment--an essentially American story in that way--an American immigrant story. I liked it and don't fault it for being about an ordinary family. But I can't say I think it's really an excellent novel, except technically. I see an enormous number of novels that show excellent craftsmanship these days, but that I know won't last, and this is one of them.
I enjoyed this book 100%. It follows a family though a lifetime together. While it is true, there is nothing extraordinary about this family and Namesake has no bizarre or tricky plot twists, it is this simplicity that made me simply fall in love with this book.
If you are looking for action packed drama, look on. I loved Namesake because the characters and relationships were so real and powerful. I cared about this family. This slice of life drama took me in completely. I did not want it to end. To top it off, the reader is wonderful as well.
I wouldn't try another book by this author. The details in the beginning were interesting but after a while became ponderous. The plot moved slowly and jumped great scans of time. Couldn't tell at the end if Goggle had learned anything about his own life as an Indian in America or about growing to be a man ready for responsibility. There was almost no point to the story.
first time for this author
The narrator was excellent.
I picked this book because it was on the 100 best books and the title was intriguing. Poor choice.
This is another of those stories that start with color and intensity in a foreign culture at a crossroad of historical events, only to end aimlessly in the contemporary USA with its life blood drained away. I would have rated it much higher if the story line had never moved so far away from its core.
This book was so well reviewed, and my lifelong friend is the daughter of Indian immigrants, so I thought I would really enjoy the story. Unfortunately I have to agree with several other reviewers who said the book was about nothing. There appeared to be no other issue to the story than the fact that the main character was embarrassed about his name. I kept waiting for something to happen that was not completely mundane. I like a very wide variety of books and never stop reading a book just because it doesn't grab me right away, but this was just painful. I actually find it kind of humorous that so many people loved this book and I think it's just awful. I feel like someone who goes to an art gallery to see some "amazing" painting that everyone is raving about, only to discover it's just a blank white canvas on display!
It is as if the story teller related the events to an encyclopedia writer. The facts are there, but I felt that the writing style lacked color and depth. There was so little detail, that much of the book felt like it was a plot summary of another book. Most conversations and events were boiled down to a couple of sentences about the topic, with few literary embellishments. This style covered the material efficiently which does allow the reader to "get it over with" quickly, which is a benefit if your only goal is to read this book as a school requirement. If you are reading for enjoyment though, a little more descriptivness might improve the story. There were some descriptions of cultural tensions, but on the whole, the lives of the characters were unremarkable with the normal ups and down of a lifetime of relationships.
This is a truly wonderful oral rendition of Lahiri's first novel. The story is, of course, beautiful; the narration is fabulous. Highly recommended.
Didn't love it, didn't hate it. Just kind of bland and boring. No real emotional involement in any of the characters lives... more like an outsider hitting the highlights of a families life.