Among the best
It completed "The Persimon Tree"
Have listened to many and this one ranks with the best
Love the combination of Bryce Courtenay & Humphrey Bower
Courtenay and Bower are born storytellers. I listened to The Persimmon Tree, and immediately followed up with this sequel, Fishing for Stars.
I enjoyed them both immensely, especially the Javanese and Japanese historical aspects, which were new to me and very interesting. Also, the insights into Japanese language and customs were interesting and entertaining.
Nick was, typically of Courtenay's characters, rather too good to be true, while Anna was beguiling, her father disgusting, the natives all very good folk and the immigrant settlers all very bad. Nevertheless, this can be overlooked in the interests of a most entertaining story. A lovely, long, good one.
Mr Bower is a brilliant narrator, and I became so engrossed in the various voices, which were constant and unflagging, that i actually forgot it was all being read by one person.
I found there was a little too much repetition, although its understandable in the second book, for those readers who hadn't read the first.
What really bored and irritated me though, was the way the author used the latter part of the novel 'Fishing for Stars' as a soapbox to preach environmentalism. On and on and on ..... and then there's this little frog you're welcome to send donations for ..... by all means, but perhaps this isn't right platform?
I am sympathetic to the cause, and very aware of the problem. I live in a country where the struggle against the savage and barbaric poaching of rhino and also elephant is a constant and heartbreaking struggle.
IMHO, too much of the frogs, rivers and environmentalism detracted from the novel and felt rammed down my throat, but i guess the point was well made and for a good cause.
You still cant go wrong with Bryce Courtenay and Humphrey Bower!
BC's books are great. And this narrator is one of the best, if not THE best. But BC has a tendency to slip into sanctimony at times. The story starts strong but, for me, toward the end especially, it gets too preachy about womens' rights, the environment, capitalism...
it's fine when the characters play out their flaws and talents but the multi page lectures on what's right and wrong were too many and too obvious.
As always, it's worth a listen, but not the best
Everything. He is a master
Having heard other Bryce Courtenay books, including The Persimmon Tree ( which is excellent and to which this is the sequel) I was excited to read the completed story of Anna. Unfortunately readers weren't warned that to do so would cost them a lot of time while the writer tried to catch everyone else up. So first and foremost, expect a lot of rehash if you've read The Persimmon Tree.
The second complaint is almost worse. As another reviewer mentioned, get ready for the attempt to be converted to a tree hugger. When I listen to audio books, I want to be taken to other places, to be immersed in entertainment and enjoyment. I do NOT purchase audio books so I get get someone else's political take on an issue. This is not entertainment since if you agree, it's like a sermon to the choir and if you disagree it's like being held captive while someone else beats your brain with their political views.
There are redeeming values to this book, but these two issues irked me so much that I was sincerely disappointed.
This is my seventh Courtenay book, and I am starting to pick up on a trend. Unfortunately too late as I struggled to finish this one. I have now gone through Courtenay's book series and have found the first book in each series by far the best. An easy five star. The last book of his series, which this one is, are painfully slow, little action, and a way for Courtenay to get all of the historical facts, he had not used to that point, into the series. I almost can't remember how much I liked the Persimmon Tree. The story plays second fiddle to the need to douse you with historical info with a dull development of the characters. Taking a break from Courtenay after this one. I will stick to his single book efforts and stay away from any future series of books. Bower as usual is great and was the only way I could have finished this book.
For me this is a type of book that always sits in your mind. Incredible story, I fell in love with the main characters in the book 1 and it was interesting to follow their story in the sequel. Can't stop. The narration is excellent! Highly recommend.
I was so impressed with Humphrey Bower's naration. His ability to portray many nationalities with accurate accents really added to my enjoyment of this book. This story of Bryce Courtenay's is so entertaining, I really appreciate the research that assists the author weaving interesting historical,
geographical, and sociological facts into a great story.
A disclaimer: I've only "read" the first hour but I was so distracted and annoyed that I needed to post. The plot, the characters, the voices, all seemed way too much like Brother Fish. It doesn't help that the first several chapters give the plot or back story in broad brush strokes so any differentiation is lost in the generalities but, to summarize: A military veteran whose true love was victimized by bad guys of an Asian persuasion, he is very wealthy from a shipping company and has a best friend who is an African American who he eventually goes into business with. I had to look up the plot of Brother Fish to make sure that the main characters name was Jacko Mackenzie and not Nick Duncan and that this wasn't some weird sequel to BF.
It certainly doesn't help that when Joe opens his mouth for the first time, Bower uses the same voice and grammar for Joe that he did for Jimmy Oldcorn.
Here's hoping the remaining 21 hours has something, anything, of an original nature to it. I've liked all of Courtenay's books before but not enough to read the same plot twice over, just with a different cast of characters.
Retired to mountains of California. Sell on eBay as Prsilla. No TV. Volunteer in wildlife rehab. Knit, sew or embroider while listening.
This book gets 5 stars because it is Courtenay. That said, I am disappointed and confused. I was not ready for Australian history, much less Indonesia or the Japanese mafia or the birth of the Australian Green party. Gosh, this book has something for everyone! I have trouble believing that a heroin addict can stay beautiful for years on end. Neither woman is all that devoted to the man because neither married him or even lived with him fulltime. Maybe I'm old-fashioned for wanting legal marriage with full penetration and maybe even babies -- and the other stuff just for fun once in a while. And I certainly don't consider fame and fortune and designer clothes a fair substitute for not achieving some kind of normal family life. Politically I sided with Marg, the animals and old growth. As for Anna, I expected healing for her! Sure she was sitting on a shitload of bad stuff, but many people manage to move on. I enjoyed the unabridged audio version of Kiana Davenport's masterpiece Song of the Exile about comfort women of the Japanese and loved it. It is about enduring and surviving; that book helped me heal my own difficulties at the time. So my attention was indeed held by some of the insights about the Japanese. I appreciate the research. And I loved some of the creative philanthropy in the book, i.e., managing a new life for the little artist who was officially dead. However, much of the book sounded more like BBC radio news than an exciting novel. Perhaps Bryce rushed to finish this book. Having Saffron do great things in the last few minutes is not my idea of a happy ending. Nick should have bailed from both of those relationships and gotten himself a proper wife. I still love this author.