While there were definitely some provocative ideas in this book, many of these ideas were overshadowed by the inundation of unfounded proposition after unfounded proposition. Throughout the book, he continued to idolize leaders and demonize managers. It is as though it never occurred to him that great leaders could also inspire great managers. Overall this book was overhyped. It was a lot of style very little substance. The book could have been made significantly better had he chosen to work with an economist or researcher who could have shown him how to support and develop his ideas more concretely.
Tribalism has evolved from the genetic, to the regional, to the religious, to the national...to the brand. A good book, but he should have hired a better narrator.
If the world is formed of tribes, and if all tribes need a leader, then surely Seth Godin is the leader of leaders. This book is so fun, informative and easily digestible that when I got to the end, I immediately hit Play and started it again. Thanks to the ideas and concepts in this book, I've brushed off my blogs and my Facebook account, and I'm working harder than ever to bring my ideas into the world by gathering together those of like minds. Read this book and join the tribe!
Wow, what an inspiring listen. This should be required listening for all corporate leaders and employees! Seth does a great job narrating...in fact, I couldn't imagine anyone else doing it. Seth is a legend.
I honestly do not know who the target audience is for this book. As an IT professional who has been out of school for a dozen years, this book was not only incorrect in most of its assumptions, but would be outright dangerous for a recent college graduate to absorb. The author makes these broad sweeping generalizations about how Any and All change is beneficial. You are a Leader if you don't listen to your boss or follow the process! (what??)
I only made it two hours into the book, but he only gave one example where he himself led a successful 'tribe'. Unfortunately, he doesn't even consider the possibility that the idea behind his education software was something people wanted to work on. He just assumes Every single time you organize a tribe, you will get the same passion and fervor as he did. Or you simply didn't organize it correctly and you failed. I thought the book might have some redeeming qualities about how to get started organizing a group online, but instead his answer was literally "you already know how to do this", and said something about having Faith in yourself. Oh. Ok. Thanks?
I was expecting to read a how-to book, but was presented with an adolescent self-help book. I do not recommend this book for anyone beyond high school. It is rather patronizing if you have any higher education.
Simply a must read for management majors or anyone looking to be their own boss. very very good. I read this for an assignment for a class but ended up enjoying it greatly.
Some books are meant to be read rather than listened. The Tribes is one of them. To fully think of all the concepts offered by the book you have to stop and think, which at the times may not be the easiest option. I would recommend everyone to buy hard copy or at least kindle version rather than audio version of this book.
With that being said, I would like to underline that the book does not offer any revolutionary ideas or concepts (at least for those who are around people quite a bit), but rather book forces reader/listener to re-think their approach to leadership and makes them reverse their stubborn ways, into more of a team oriented approach.
Examples given in the book are great, and easy to follow. I would recommend this book to anyone, specially younger people who are looking to make a difference.