This is a simply fabulous book whether you're into diving or not. A remarkable story, remarkable divers, well researched and well told - I often found myself holding my breath. Watching the video documentary added another dimension but I'm so glad I had read the book first. Thankyou Bill, John and Ritchie (et al) for your effort - and Robert for telling their story.
One of the best non-fiction I've ever read, and I've read alot. I had to keep reminding myself that these events and characters are real! A Great Read!
I listened to this book on a very exciting drive from Mammoth last year, during a fantastic show storm. This story kept me entertained the entire time. As a SCUBA diver and a sometimes too inquisitive individual, I loved the tale. It was a bit long, but then as the Unabridged version, you sort of expect it to be. I have highly recommeneded this book to friends and will continue to do so.
This non-fictional account of two men risking their lives to identify a sunken German U-Boat from WWII is far from excellent. The first half of this book becomes very preachy (as if teaching the reader what to do when diving) and the context is choppy. All throughout Shadow Divers the author leads the reader far off subject for reasons not necessary. Although true, the author continuously describes the characters in such an unrealistic way it discredits the entire story. Furthermore, the author is so repetitive, reading the book seems like an eternity.
Intensely interesting, thoroughly engaging story overcomes awful narration (why hire a blaring newsreel monotone when highly sensitive narrative inflection is required?). Get past the voice and the occasional weak prose by a first-time author -- who makes amends by providing a gerth of thoroughly-research facts, representations, and historical context -- and enjoy a great, great listen.
This is a very interesting story and overall it is well told. The author, however, tries a bit too hard to make the prose more "interesting" by adding improbable metaphors and extravagent phrasing where more simple phrasing would do. The result of this "purple prose" is that I often found myself laughing outloud at moments that were intended to be climactic! As another reviewer mentioned, the narrator also leaves a bit to be desired. In summary: a very good story reasonably well told.
Just by listening to the first hour becomes apparent that the author had to butter up his subjects. Whether so they would let him write their story at all or charge him less royalty, it doesn't matter. The first character you meet was once successful but is now little more than a sad drunk whose wife and kids left him. However, he is portrayed as a great man, who left his family to live a bachelor's life. This kind of blatant glorification rankles me and I was unable to finish the book. The other reviews are universally good, however, so perhaps I'm the only one annoyed by this flaw. By all means, try this book; but only download the first section so you can return it if you find it irritating.