The Physic of Deliverance Dane is a really compelling story. It's well written and the narrator Katherine Helgren does a good job of all the character voices.
The story was interesting enough to keep me genuinely curious as to the outcome, and I thoroughly enjoyed the historical flashbacks. The female characters were believable and interesting, but the males were a bit caricatured, so the climax wasn't much of a surprise. I do wish the author had been as thorough in her research of modern medical care as she was with the historical aspects, and the narrator's reading tended toward melodramatic. But the story of Deliverance and her family and Connie's journey toward discovery was engaging enough to make this book a worthwhile listen.
The book started off okay, but then it went off the rails. It starts off as a historical fiction, but it moves squarely into the realm of fantasy about half way through the book. The romance isn't terribly compelling, yet we are supposed to believe that the main character's love for the boy is the driving force behind everything else. Likewise, the villain character makes no sense whatsoever, and his motivation requires more suspension of disbelief than the witchcraft.
Steeped in the Salem hysteria of 1692 & brought to current times, time may have only lessened the social outcomes of being "different". the paranoia & fear of the unknown is still powerful, but never more powerful than it is in our own self. A mysterious, historical story of witches, religion & some cunning women!
I appreciated the in-depth historical research the author did for this book. In fact, the postscript was one of my favorite parts, as she explained which parts were historically accurate and which had been partly or wholly factionalized. Also, any graduate student or post-graduate will relate to the portrayal of grad student life which was clearly drawn from the author's own experience. I loved this book!
Wonderfully written and very well performed. This book is very enjoyable as well as having a more than realistic historic appeal.
I must say I was not only enthralled by this book but totally blown away. I just wish this was a series and the book didn't end so fast. I nearly fumed and ranted, and got out my Good Reads to leave a bad comment when she drops 'the recipe book' in the fire. How could someone who has such great respect for books do such a thing! We at the end of the book she does say that it's all on microfilm, but still, it's not the same thing!!
Other than that small hiccup I really enjoyed the book.
I liked this book a lot. It was recommended to me by Audible based on a previous listen: "A Discovery of Witches". I liked "discovery" better, but still really enjoyed this listen.
The book has a similar, creepy feeling. Not scary at all, just a feeling that something could be lurking around the next corner.
I would also compare this book to two others - well one book and a movie. The Physick Book of Deliverance Dane could be compared to National Treasure (not sure if its a book) - in some ways. It is similar in that it involves a search for something historical and there are a series of clues to unravel. I really enjoyed the look into history this book offered - albeit it highly fictional. I still felt I learned something about the Salem Witch trials and 'cunning' people of that day.
I think my favorite part was the going back and forth to different women in time, and thus my comparison to a third story: Joy Luck Club. In Joy Luck Club I enjoyed the understanding that steadily grew through the story as we learned more about each woman. The Physick Book of Deliverance Dane has that same feel to it - although it does not go as indepth about each woman. What we readers get is glances or flashes back in history that give insight into the current day. The connection to the past gains more momentum and meaning as the book moves on, which is why I think some reviewers say they thought the beginning of the book moved slowly.
When deciding to read this book I read some reviews. One person commented that the current day character was dull in comparison to the people of the past. I can understand that comment, but I wanted to offer a different opinion. I felt the current day character becomes more interesting as she becomes more connected with her past. I like that!
Anyway - good solid book. If you liked "Discovery of Witches", "National Treasure" and "Joy Luck Club" - this is a good book for you!
This book reminded me of a small-scale daVinci Code. There's the learning about the culture of the times of the Salem witch trials, the clothing of the people, a love interest, and even some latin. There's a chase to find information and keep it away from the bad guy.
This narrator does a great job with accents. Her speaking is crisp and concise.
It would be hard for me to come up with a name for this novel that is more intriguing than the current title.
I learned a great deal of information from this book and learning is key to understanding. Please make more books like this available.
This book has some interesting ideas about the causes of the Salem witch trials but unfortunately degenerates into an overwrought supernatural thriller. After its pseudo-scholarly beginning, this is was not what I was expecting or had hoped for. While some interesting details of the trials are included, be aware that some of the author's so-called “facts” are inaccurate or have been discredited by current historical research.