wow, this is one of those reviews that you never want to write...this book has been a struggle to listen to, and i am still not done. i listen at work and am finding it very difficult to follow this book. the narrators i have heard have all been excellent, but the story starts off very confusing and is written in more of a literary/fancy style than i normally read, so please don't pass over this book on my account. twice, i have started other books and come back as the premise of the book sounds great...so far, however, i'm not on cloud atlas 9
Multiple narrators without transitions between narrations or transitions between sections.
Some sections or speakers of this book seem to ramble on and do not connect to other sections and fail to hold my interest.
This novel had received so much attention and seemed so interesting that I decided to listen. I thought the beginning of the first story was okay but soon began to sense that there was going to be much more here...and there was. David Mitchell's story and a wonderful group of readers bring you deeper and deeper into stories that are very much related. I don't want to give anything away but you will be delighted with where you are taken.
I really tried to get through it. I made it to the third story couldn't take it anymore. There are no redeeming qualities to give this book. I can't believe this was made into a movie and now I understand why its tanking.
No - he is not a good storyteller. Cloud Atlas had a great concept but the author could not pull it off.
They were okay - good accents.
They were all equally uninspiring.
I believe the movie will be much better then the book. The author just could not pull it off, good idea, bad execution!
It was complicated and uninteresting and made more complicated and uninteresting by the narrators. I can stomach a poor read of a good book but a poor read of a boring story and I'm out.
No, not because this was that bad but there are many that are better.
The narrators were very good, definitely a high point for me. Mitchell's use of language and how the narrators used them was impressive.
I listened to this knowing the movie was coming out. Haven't seen the movie yet but I am curious to see how it is.
Just fabulous. Complex and takes a while to get your mind around what is going on, but once immersed Cloud Atlas is wonderful and superbly crafted. I read the de Zoet book first, which I also recommend, but don't be deceived with Cloud Altas - it is not a period piece but is rather an imaginative voyage through time with first rate narration, plot lines and character development. Easily one to read/listen to twice. Leaves you wanted more, like a perfect dinner that was just right. I am stunned at the brilliance of David Mitchell. Very original. Recommended.
I focus on fiction, sci-fi, fantasy, science, history, politics and read a lot. I try to review everything I read.
Given the many excellent reviews that led me to this novel, I expected quite a bit. Although this was not a bad book, I was not terribly impressed. Although it had a slightly interesting structure, it was far from groundbreaking. The various novelettes are, on there own, passable, but they are only loosely linked. Although there is an overall theme, it was hardly unique or impressive. The character development is in the style of a novel, but with the word count of several short stories – which I found limiting. Yes, the novel echoes Melville, Huxley, Steinbeck and Sterne, but it is only a weak, derivative, echo. While listening to this novel I was consistently thinking about the far more perfect novels the imitative writing brought to mind. Near the half-way point I nearly gave up listening, but the stories finally did link and the novel did have a semi-coherent (if old hat) message. The second half was much more interesting than the first half. At the end I was only disappointed because I expected so much.
I've contemplated listening to this book for quite some time, but was wary because of some negative reviews. I am so glad I took the risk. This may be one of the most brilliantly written and narrated books I've experienced. Even if one doesn't immediately get all the connections between the stories, each one is noteworthy in inself. I found myself thinking back on it long after it was complete. I definitely need a second listen, and look forward to it.