My family is first. Secondly, I play golf with my friends and hike with a book.
I have enjoyed all of Anchee Min's books. I love reading about Chinese culture and especially the methods women used to gain their own sort of power against, but through the men. This book never caught my attention because the narrator was so flat. She did have a nice Asian tone to her voice, but no character or life to the dialogue. I had to stop mid-way through -- something I avoid doing with vigor. Try the "sample" and if the reader resonates with you, buy the book.
This book was an ok read. Seemed to have dragged on and on and ended in a disappointing way.
The narrator made this book even more worse. I could hear her swallowing and her throat making noises. It made the book worse than it was.
Shall we have the narrator or the editor of this recording whipped? What a shame! It's a great story of imperial China; it's accurate in its history and artful in its fiction. But it was impossible not to be frequently distracted and annoyed by the narrator's salivating, swallowing, and flat reading. My condolences to the author.
What I didnt like:
The Narrator, she read like she was 1/2 asleep and kept on swallowing into the microphone which was very distracting. She also seemed to take long pauses in the middle of a sentence.
The story was pretty slow and dwelt primarily on Chinese court ediquet. Even at the few sensual and suspensful parts the narrator made me feel like I was falling asleep.
What I liked:
The historical acuracy. The book followed true historical events very well. (Maybe that is why the story was so slow)
I bought the unabridged version, got Part 1 & 2, each close to 9 hours. The end of Part 2 is NOT the end of the book!! I would like to get the rest, but you do not show a Part 3.
Having read a number of books in this genre, this one does not particularly stand out as exceptional or even good. The writing is disjointed and the author leaves many loose threads in her descriptions and the main character is as flat as a pancake. As for the audio bit, the narrator, in addition to the swallowing annoyance, reads the book as if it were her grocery list. I am disappointed to have even wasted one of my credits on this book.
I love stories that are well told, and an audio format is the type which requires excellent articulate reading. Unfortunately, I could not appreciate the narration due to the reader's constant thick sound of swallowing. This may be a story as great as any epic saga, but it's proportions are greatly reduced by it's narrator's clearly audible cotton mouth. Nobody wants to hear saliva coming through their speakers unless the story is about that.
The depth of the the history, culture, and humanity expessesed in the telling of this astonishing life story cannot help but to enrich you long after you have listened to the last of this book
I think this probably was a good book. I will not know if they do not re-record, because the swallowing - the very loud, disgusting swallowing - of the narrator caused me to finally have to put it down. I kept thinking I would get used to it, but I didn't and it began to make me want to gag. I understand people swallow, but I have never heard it on an audiobook. Edit the book, get rid of the swallowing, please!