I wonder if savants and geniuses have fever dreams that feel like this. Compelling, principled and absolutely enrapturing. Chapeau, Mieville, chapeau. I would read a whole novel about The Torque, fyi... if you feel like it... please.
This is a very well written book, and Mieville is a very talented writer. He has a wildly vivid imagination, and he was able to transport me thoroughly to his world he has created. It did take me a little to get into the story, because Mieville's writing style is pretty unique and it took a while for my brain to synchronize with his imagery. Once I got locked in though, it was pretty awesome. It's basically a steam punkish world, with sci-fi and fantasy all mashed together,and mashed together brilliantly. I was wondering when I would finally listen to a book like this, and I picked a very good one to start with.
His character descriptions, to include all of the amazing different races were stunning. He just didn't lightly touch on each character in this world, but really fully flushed out each one, including even the minor ones which just made this world that much deeper.
Mieville developed a pretty basic main story-line, but it was really just used as a fulcrum for all of the sub-plots and the shadow plot-line. Just reading the summary of the book, I didn't think it would hold me attention, but I was riveted until almost the end.
Now, I do have one huge problem with this book, and it's purely personal. Mieville made some choices with how he ended this book with some characters and some of the plot lines which I hated, and pretty much tainted the whole book for me. For a writer of Mieville's obvious talent, he really picked some of the lame duck endings that sub-par writers would choose, and he knows better. I'm not going to spoil it for you, but you'll understand what I'm talking about when you see them.
Overall, this is a very good book and I love Mieville's writing style. If you've always wanted to listen to a world with very strong steam punk influence, sci-fi, fantasy, and any other cool genre you've liked than this is the book for you. Mieville is able to merge all of these worlds seamlessly and was such a treat to venture into. Just for my personal preference, I hated the ending, but for most of you out there this may not be an issue. Even with the lazy ending, I would still highly recommend this story and I"m looking forward to some more Mieville books.
Create an ending worthy of the story.
Good story and character development , ending needs to be less abrupt.
Hard Sci-Fi Connoiseur.
A lot of folks might have some trouble buying into to Mieville's worlds but for my money he's the best in the business at odd, steam-punk sci-fi / fantasy (honestly not sure how you categorize it). Of his novels this seems to flow most smoothly - the characters are rich and interesting. The city is alive and vibrant. All nicely complimented by John Lee's fantastic narration (the guy's a master).
I have no problems with aliens, even a giant slew of highly improbable ones inhabiting the same city. I do have problems with a story that makes little sense, relies heavily on absurd coincidence, and seems to go on and on and on.
John Lee is superb as always. Unfortunately, he has little to work with here.
this is difficult to answer. it's a good story, one worth listening to, but there is so much unnecessary detail that distracts from the main story. Melville probably should have saved all the extra details for different books.
Genres: Fantasy, Steam Punk, Adventure
Character Development: 4/5
Storytelling Skill: 5/5
This was my first true 'steam punk' novel, and I greatly enjoyed it. The world is an imaginative layering of ideas, cultures, forces, and powers. It was very representative of the steam punk imagery I have seen. The characters are realistic and human (or non-human, as the case may be). Both the author and the narrator did a wonderful job of keeping the characters distinct and interesting. It was difficult to pick out the overall plot-line until towards the end of the story because there were so many seemingly unrelated events happening all over the city, bet each was so enthralling that I just wanted more. The only reason that this book didn't get a 5/5 overall is that I prefer stories which touch on what it means to be human in some way, and moves me deeply. This story did not even attempt to touch me on that level, only to entertain, but it entertained VERY well.
An imaginitive, creative, fantastically new world. A contrived, middling plot. Grotesqueries out the wazoo. If youre int he mood for something brutally imaginitive, dark, grimy and vulgar, go for it. Mieville paints a great picture but bites off a little more than he can chew when it comes to plot.
China Meiville has created an urban nightmare that feels hopelessly real and peopled it with corruption, compassion and humanity. Gorgeous writing. The city is the vastest character in the book, and that's saying something in this book with people who still haunt me years after I read it. Since the novel I love is so drippingly rich in description I wondered if it could work as an audiobook. Thank you, John Lee! There are few novels I read twice, but I have both read and listened to Perdido Street Station twice. That's four swampy excursions into the fetid, amazing neighborhoods of New Crobuzon.
This book was an enjoyable listen once I allowed myself to relax into its nonlinear mentality, however, the pacing of the novel needs work. The book is too long, and feels like it should have ended when the killer moth is killed, but instead, three new (and presumably disposable) characters are introduced and the hunt drags on. Lynn, the lover introduced early in the book, with much care and description, languishes the whole book and only appears briefly (and unsatisfyingly) in the end. Another character, wingless and morose throughout, starts to narrate and describe his own sudden inner change into an active and expressive person and it feels as if this is a tacked-on explanation because otherwise the story would become totally unclear. I enjoyed "The City and The City" better.