i have 4 things to say about this book:
1. the narration is excellent
2. the romance is...very romantic
3. the history is...fun
4. the "naughty" stuff is...(see below)
it's common for romance novels, especially ones that appeal to medieval European settings, to bring in sexually charged themes of bondage, whipping, and nonconsensual intercourse. this book goes rather SO far in that direction, though, that it distracts from the otherwise dignified plot.
Below is an abbreviated breakdown of the action, just to let you know just how kinky things get.
MH=Male Hero / MF=Female Heroine / MV=Main Villain / V=Villain
1) MV threatens to force himself onto FH
2) random V's threaten to force themselves onto FH
3) MV whips MH and forces himself onto MH's sister
4) 2 V's force themselves on FH in front of MH
5) MV forces himself on FH in front of MH
6) MH whips FH (gives her a "strapping")
7) MV tortures MH
8) MV forces himself on MH (!!!)
9) FH pretends to be MV in (non-psychologist approved) reenactment of #8 designed to "cure" him of his shame (?!)
and all of this in lurid detail, with a great deal of time spent recalling past whippings and beatings and tortures. not sure how all this made it past the editor, but...
at least now you're warned, and there is a good story and some good writing buried in there!
I didn't like it!
I really can't understand the high ratings for this book. The performance was great, but the story drove me crazy.
A time travel book, by means of a witch-craft and a Henge, but that's where the coolness ends. The Heroine of the book, Claire, travels back in time 200 years in Highland Scotland. But when she arrives, there is much too little history and too much of the story revolving around the Claire's emotional turmoil. The Publisher's summary describes a county war-torn by raiding Clans. The only battles here are in the heads of the characters - not enough action and too much syrupy romance.
Guys won't like it. Women wanting a strong Heroine lead might... except that Claire can hardly do a thing to save herself in the many situations she finds herself, or gets herself into.
I think a teenager or young 20-something would enjoy the steamy scenes.
The narrator was superb and the reason why I listened to this to the bitter, boring end.
Better historical context required.
I cannot imagine why this was picked for me. I kept hoping it would get more interesting but it never made it there.
I only made it about 1/3 through-- that's all I could stand. I'm sure it may get better as it gets on, but it just wasn't for me. I did quite enjoy the narrator, in spite of that.
I have edited 38 national best sellers and had a writing fellowship from the National Endowment for the Humanities.
I got through part one, which was pretty good, and then a quarter of part two, when the heroine turned into an idiot, and I couldn't stand it anymore.
The romance genre depends upon tension between the lovers, and much of the strife is based on misunderstandings. I get that. But the heroine's thought processes, perceptions, attitude, and behavior were maddening and in some cases inexcusable. When I couldn't sympathize with her anymore, when I didn't care what happened to her, I knew it was time to exchange this book for another.
Kudos to the narrator. She was fabulous.
Airheaded young girls or lonely women.
Best suggest this as an entry title just before 50 shades of grey.
The almost complete lack of smart and intelligent commentary. Only a long winded story about nothing in particular.
There was the gay aspect of it, but instead of using some clever situations and remarks to shed some light on this controversial topic, she instead resolved to give one gay character some pedophile inclinations and make the other the very pinnacle of evil and sadism.
It felt like eating a party size bag of chips, not particularly bad, not particularly good either, yet you are left with very little nutrition and it was mostly just a waste of time.
The performance was very good, I think that was what kept me going actually.
The sex scenes!
The author tries really really hard, and it ends up sounding like a caricature, catapulting the reader out of any immersion they might have achieved.
And boy do the main characters go at it like rabbits!
Seemed like every chapter I had to sit through and listen at least a couple of time about his 'brass rod', her soft breasts or her moaning and pushing against him while his manliness heaved deep inside of her... Or something of that sort. You get the picture.
So I begrudgingly moaned and listened to the '50 shades of tartan grey' that littered an otherwise quaint if rather bland story. I'm a masochist I guess.
A missed opportunity for social commentary. Having a woman travel through time, was a great stage to compare and show how times have changed or stayed the same.
Instead, the author chose to stick with the tried, true and mind blastingly boring road of setting up a romance between a well chiseled hunk and a married woman.
Sure there was the aspect of her husband being in a completely different time, but that was glossed over in favor of some steamy sex scenes. Smh...
Guess that's what I get for going after 33 hour books based only on hollow reviews.
I found this book under the Scifi/fantasy section, and it definitely should not have been there. I've managed to make it to chap. 22 and except for one very brief moment of traveling through time in the beginning, there has been no science fiction in this book. And the only fantasy involved would be the copious amounts of sex with kilt-clad Scotsmen. I suppose that could be someone's idea of a fantasy, but not the kind you expect to find in the Sci-fi/fantasy category. This book is a very, very long romance novel of the trashy paperback sort. If that is what you are buying it for, you will probably love it, but if you were looking for Sci-fi, like me, forget it.
If you are a guy, pass it up. If you don't like soap operas, men in kilts who do nothing but fight, drink, and have sex, or if you blush easily, pass it up.
On the plus side, the narrator does an excellent job. She does well with both the Scot and British accents as well as the male and female characters. She's easy to understand and reads with feeling.
I thought this was a historical romance series, but it must be the least romantic one ever. Is it supposed to be literary BDSM fare, some sort of better-written Fifty Shades? I only made it about halfway through before giving up in disgust. The style is not terrible, but the characters, especially the heroine, are awful.
Our heroine is a mostly-unconcerned bigamist, marrying after six weeks of time travel. Her chief antagonist and a sadistic tormentor in the past is the double of her 1940s husband. Her new 1740s husband gets a kick out of beating her with his belt, and she essentially acquiesces to his wisdom in doing so. He then basically says he'll rape her, except she gives in, so - not sure how we tally that one. Claire hadn't made much effort to get back to her time by the time I gave up, but she had been nearly-raped 3 or 4 times and there's been the one beating of her and several beatings or stories of beatings or other abuse of Jamie or other characters. It feels like she's a feckless wimp and our author is getting a kick out of brutalizing Claire a little and Jamie a lot.
I don't know what other people get out of this, but I didn't want to subject myself to 16 more hours. From what I've read since, it sounds like it just gets uglier.
Claire. And 1740s Randall.
Finally! Unabridged Gabladon! I had resorted to getting them at the library and painstakingly downloading the cd's to my computer. Please get all of them!!! I'm up as far as Voyager.
Davina Porter is an excellent narrator accomplishing dialect and gender changes so the characters come to life in a glorious and colorful way.
Not one word left out and beautifully read. A true treat to listen to again and again.
This book is very violent with details of flogging, attempted rape, brutal beatings, rough sex, and even the child birth is brutal. The Author barely even addresses the fact that Claire has left behind another life. Very little is said about her former life. The narrator is very good with the voices and the accents.