This is the first time I've tried to write a review, so bear with me. I liked Slight Trick of the Mind. It was a nice listen. Well read and written. I will listen to it again sometime. There is a mystery to solve and some insight into Sherlock's life as an older man.
I was very much looking forward to listening to this book, having been a Holmes fan from a young age, both through the books and various films and BBC productions. Although read beautifully by the narrator, who does an excellent job of performing the different voices, I was very disappointed that the focus of the story centered primarily around the post-WWII history and culture of Japan and a male lead Japanese character. There is a brief flashback on a case that Holmes had sleuthed in the past, but this gets lost with the Japanese focus of the story. If you want a true Holmesian mystery set in Englad, I'd suggest you skip this recording and choose from the originals written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book though if you are looking for a Sherlock Holmes mystery this is not. This book is another type of mystery looking into the personal thoughts and feelings of a legendary literary character. The narrator was perfect and drew me into the book immediately. This once fearless and magnificent man is now near the end of his life but as the story unfolds you realize that what seemed to most of us to be an exciting and fulfilling life, actually had a lot of emptiness. It's an exploration of the humanity of the greatest and most memorable detective.
I downloaded this audio because I really loved the film that is based on it, Mr. Holmes, played by Ian McKellan who brought an emotional depth to an aged Holmes that I hadn't seen before. The movie was warm with a satisfying ending. Not so with the book. It is rare that I enjoyed a film more than the book, but in this case I did. The writer of the film did an excellent job of taking a book which seemed disjointed and pulling it into a story that made better sense. There were numerous differences between the character portrayals and events between both, and I still prefer the film's version. Simon Jones did an excellent job with the narration and the book held my interest. Just slightly disappointed.
I felt like these three storylines didn't go anywhere. Overall a frustrating listen, though the reader's voice was wonderful. It might have worked better if the main character were not Sherlock Holmes. It would not have created an expectation of twists and mysteries and clever endings in me.
Yes. Absolutely captivating.
I rushed to listen to this one in preparation of seeing the movie with friends. I hung on every word. It drove me a little crazy, but in a good way, trying to link the mysteries with real Doyle characters. The movie had a different ending, but I forgave them as it was less heartbreaking their way.
This is a very good story with a different side to the Worlds Greatest Detective ! Mr. Holmes is Softer and more Human than ever before. Perfect for the Sherlock Holmes fan , there is a Movie now out based on this Book Mr. Holmes ! , a must see Movie as well , overall a must read for anyone who loves Holmes, will surprise you 🇬🇧
The Path Between the Seas to The Great Bridge ~ Kagan's Peloponnesian War to Gaddis' Cold One ~ Mornings on Horseback to a River of Doubt ~ Tom to Huck ~ Lennie to Charley ~ Cadfael to Cross ~ Rhyme to Reacher ~ Blomkvist and Salander to Wallander and Wallander ~ Moving Cheese or Eating Frogs ~ On the Road and Into Thin Air ~ The End of History to A Short History of Everything to ... well ... everything else.
Sherlock Holmes remains a literary and box office powerhouse. Or, at least, that's the only reasonable explanation for the success of this book.
On the other hand, Mitch Cullin's contribution to the Holmes canon is, sadly, forgettable.
Cullin offers us a novel in three parts -- three story lines set in two different periods of Holmes' life. Three new glimpses into the life of Sherlock Holmes could be treasures. But here, they're not. None of these stories is even especially interesting or exciting or engaging.
With Holmes, we expect a mystery to challenge and confound us. There really aren't any here.
With Holmes, we expect demonstrations of observation and deduction that cause us to marvel. Here, we don't find much at which to marvel.
With Holmes, we expect the tale to carry us away to his world as the original stories would: to his rooms on Baker Street or to Baskerville Hall or atop Reichenbach Falls. Here, the narrative has no power to take us anywhere. We remain firmly set in our own time and place and world.
But still, this is Holmes, so we can hope.
Surely Cullin will draw his story lines together and redeem his entire novel in an exciting denouement. How could we expect anything else for Conan Doyle's great detective?
But that never happens, either. Cullin allows each story to wander off on its own and gently fade away. There are no surprises. There are no mysteries solved. There are no exciting moments. There are no characters we will remember. There is no closure.
There is only a forgettable and unsatisfying novel that serves only to remind us that even great lives have dull moments.
Skip this one.
Oddly enough, this is one time I will say that the movie worked better, though I have my quibbles with that as well. The book is essentially three tales, but they never overlap enough thematically to make a satisfying conclusion. The audio is beautifully performed, however, and kept me listening. A lesser performance would have had me abandoning this book before the end.
This is a perfectly crommulent book, it's just not the book you probably think it is. If you are expecting a battle of wits between an aging Holmes and an evil archvillian, forget it. Although Holmes does solve a few minor mysteries, this book is about an imperfect though great aging man dealing with loss and regret.