A series of shorter more focused books would have been much more enjoyable -- and satisfying. This, like his other work, has a feeling of autobiography, still, I didn't need the entire thing in one "read". I was exhausted and not all that enriched by the experience of listening to this book.
I just could not get into this story ; and the southern voice just grated on my nerves after awhile
Yes. I love Pat Conroy's writing but this book is just too long.
Sure. Love his writing. LIke shorter books.
Yes. Easy to listen to.
Well, it was alot of time. I wished it would have ended sooner.
Conroy had several good stories and not sure why he felt he had to compress them all in one book. I also didn't think he added value by having his own version of "Old Man and the Sea" in the middle of the book. We already knew these boys were bonded so that was dropped in and added no value.
While it is interesting, it is way too long, laced with barely believable language, incidents and encounters.
Beach Music is a sweeping, stirring, at times kind of rambling saga that shows Pat Conroy for the most part doing what he does best—setting real and believable characters in lush, wonderful settings amidst the very best of human relationships and the very worst of human cruelty. It features all the usual themes familiar to Conroy fans—family relationships, abuse, addiction, sports, mental illness, tragedy—and of course the ever-present Low Country of South Carolina. In this book, however, Conroy takes things a bit further, setting a significant portion of the book in Rome and even reliving two characters’ recollections of the horrors of the Holocaust.
As in all Conroy novels, it is the characters’ relationships and interactions that drive the story. From the opening pages to the somewhat drawn-out ending, Jack McCall’s relationships with his parents, his brothers, and his close-knit circle of friends provide story element after story element. From four high-school boys lost at sea in an open boat to a campus prank gone horribly wrong to inadvertent murder and an international flight from justice, Conroy reaches deep into each character’s backstory to provide a multilayered tapestry of affection and, in many cases, dysfunction.
This is not Conroy’s best work, though it may be his most ambitious. There are some surprising miscues, including several repeated dialog segments and at least one character that seems to have been forgotten about for most of the second half of the book. Nevertheless, the overall strength of the writing manages to make up for what might otherwise be distractions.
The audiobook, while a far cry from the artistry of Frank Muller’s narration of The Prince of Tides, is smooth and enjoyable. Jonathan Marosz’s Southern drawl seems a bit affected at times, but in general he provides fairly accurate and consistent character voices, and the pacing is good throughout.
The story contains the usual amount of language and rough content. Because portions of this book deal with the Holocaust, there is perhaps more dark content here than in Conroy’s others. But as always, Conroy dwells on the horrors people can inflict on each other only as much as is needed to bring out the wonder and joy that comes when individuals and communities overcome such obstacles.
Beach Music, though flawed, is a beautiful book, full of rich characterizations, incredible settings, and the indomitable buoyancy of the human spirit. Pat Conroy fans will enjoy the familiar themes and literary patterns, and the uninitiated will be treated to a wonderful introduction to one of modern America’s truly great authors.
Pat Conroy is an outstanding story teller. When listening I feel as though I am in the room with the characters.
4 young boys fishing on the open ocean...each dealing with adventure in their own way.
Jonathan is a fantastic narrator! It is so hard to choose a favorite.
Many, many moments...
Don't miss this book. It reaches deeply and stays forever.
Pat Conroy is one of the great American storytellers. Conroy's best novels weave together stories of the past to support a grand, almost archetypal story of the here and now. Beach Music felt quite the opposite, as though Conroy had several sweeping stories of the past that he really wanted to use and cobbled together a larger story of two simultaneous gatherings in the life of a Hero only to give the short stories context. The makeshift feeling context holds several superb and divergent short stories of Polish Ghettos under the Nazis, the Vietnam anti war movement, castaway boys on a little boat and many others.
While listening to Beach Music, I kept thinking that if I were reading the book, I probably would not have finished it- but at the same time, lamented the pairing of Jonathan Marosz's very fine, almost urbane narration with Conroy's laid back storytelling style. I wanted a smoother, slower voice that dripped with the honey of the Carolina coast.
Although I think Beach Music would have better been presented as a compilation of short stories, I recommend it: but not for two credits.
Beach Music is another outstanding Pat Conroy Book! I have procrastinated reading Beach Music for about 9 months, moving other Conroy books ahead of it. The reason for the delay was due to the story description not sounding as though the topic of the story would interest me, The use of 2 audible credits, The Title of the book sounding like some romantic sappy romance novel, and the book cover falsely confirming the book was probably a sappy love story. (The 2 best Conroy books available have the 2 most misleading titles. When I tell people my favorite all time book is The Prince of Tides, I usually hear, "You? isn't that a romance novel?" Thank you Barbara Streisand for killing potential book sales with your movie that doesn't remotely resemble the content of the book)
Once I hit play and started in on Beach Music it quickly moved up my list of favorites. After reading / listening to The Prince of Tides last summer I came away wanting my next read to be as good as P.O.T. This is that book! I've now listened to The Lords of Discipline, The Great Santini, South of Broad, and The Prince of Tides and this book feels the closest to The Prince of Tides as all of them!
The narration was excellent though Marosz wasn't able to capture the lightning in a bottle quite as well when it comes to Conroy's sarcastic humor like Frank Muller did in Prince of Tides. But I don't think anyone can recreate Muller's narration miracle in Prince of Tides.
The only criticism I have is what is beginning to appear as the "Conroy comfort zone" As mentioned, I've now read / listened to 5 of Conroy's books and the same story lines with different characters and situations keep popping up in each book. This was the first book of his I listened to and thought to myself on multiple occasions "Again? We've already gone down this road before in 4 other books" It's starting to feel as though these certain subjects are a comfort zone. As though he hits writers block and brings in a theme or topic from an older book changing the details around while keeping the big picture the same.
With that said... Read this one and read the Prince of Tides. In my opinion The 2 best Conroy books. then Lords, then South of Broad, then the Great Santini. Next up on my list is the water is wide.
I first head this book years ago on audio cassettes and was entranced by the flow of the story and the narrator's (Frank Muller) ability to elevate the story even above Pat Conroy's captivating prose. While I am glad to have an audio copy of this book to listen to now and again at work, this narrator's version jangles harshly. Every time I heard him doing the voice for John Hardy, Mike Hess, and Lia I fell out of the stream of the story.
English is not my first language, but this audiobook is easy to understand and I loved it. Beach Music is one of my Top 10 books ...