I struggled to finish it. very descriptive author. but little to no climax. Felt very long. And character names were extremely hard to remember who was who. Prud Proud etc. I will not be listening to another one.
I don't like ranking books that I have read or listened to. I love them all equally for different reasons.
SO MANY! However each memorable moment for me was a poignant moment in the book, and write about it would spoil the book for anyone who happens to read this review.
Sandra was very good at maintaining the same pitch and tones for the different characters (of which there are many) throughout the entire book (which is quite long).
No, only because I like to listen them over several days.
Fascinating story, good narration. I had read this as an assignment in high school and remember liking it then, however I feel that I have a greater appreciation of the book now many years later with more life experiences.
Ala would be the obvious first choice, but I found that I developed a great admiration for Brun, Esa, & Creb as well. Ala is the focal point of the book/series so she is most prominent. Brun shows great leadership, Esa & Creb devotion and love for one that is so different from themselves.
I believe this was my first Burr performance, however I've already started on book 2 in the series and look forward to the rest of the series under her skillful narration.
Many, many moments moved me, but I don't want to spoil them for first time listeners. I will say that the life of the clan opens your eyes to just how much we have available to us with today's modern conveniences.
This book is well worth the investment in time it takes to listen.
I was dubious when I ordered this book on Audible. Could it possibly stand up to the joy I felt reading her books over the many years? When it started I was unimpressed; but as it went on, I became entranced just as I did when reading the books originally. I ordered the next one (my favorite) as soon as it ended, and I suspect I will read it next before the half dozen books waiting for me in my Library. What better holiday treat could there be?
Right up there with Anne Mccaffey. I have loved the Earth's Children series since I first started reading them back in 1980, with Clan of the Cave Bear through The Land Of Painted Caves. Now to listen to the stories again it's like coming home to an old friend.
I love how real it all sounds.
I have not listened to her before, but her voice and inflection are perfect for this series.
See your prehistoric life, not as anthropologists have tried to make you believe, but come to life in full rich detail.
If you miss any of this series, well as one foodie chef is fond of saying, your Mama's should slap you into next week.
Although it started out a little tedious for me, the plot drove me forward. The story centered around a clan of Neanderthals helping Ayla survive, and the reader was introduced to a lot of information about how they lived and what it was like. I appreciated the descriptions, though it seemed overly-educational and less storyteller-ish much of the time. The author also seemed to switch perspective almost at random, but I didn't mind that too much.
The characters in this story were well developed and very interesting. I have not read the rest of the series, and I might not check out the sequels, but this particular novel was a good read. You become invested in Ayla's life and well-being and it is also fascinating to see the author's research and interpretation of Neanderthals brought forth. The topic of sex is not ignored, but it is also not spoken of in much detail, which I further appreciated.
I didn't like the narration very much, and I could tell the production was low quality. Sometimes it changed volume or it sounded like there was some slight noise in the background, like an air conditioner running. I'm not sure what it was that annoyed me about the reader herself, but I didn't fully appreciate her voice and there was a word or two that she pronounced strangely. I think I also disliked it when she tried to do different kinds of voices. For the most part it was tolerable after the first few chapters. Since I know I won't read a physical copy, I stuck with it out of curiosity.
Overall, a good choice to read, just be prepared for the annoying narration and occasional textbook-like pieces of clan life.
A classic, great concept and storyline, the best of the series.
The narrator raced through the reading. It was very hard to follow due to the rapidity of the narration, as well as the monotone timbre of the voice.
I really liked this story, really I did, but the repetitiveness of the whole >you're a woman you can't do that >yes I can >punishment cycle really wore on. I'll keep reading/listening to the series because my sister really likes it and wants somebody to discuss it with but dang. I hope the next book is less repetitive and more fun to read.