This is not my usual genre. I tend to stick to thrillers. However this was compelling, interesting, and informative. The writing holds the attention and the performance is top notch. This was worth straying from fiction.
Yes. However understand that this book chronicles 4 years that the author spent living among the gangs of the Chicago housing projects. It's not intended to be a fluffy story. If you really want to understand how a gang organizes itself, draw parallels to to modern business, get more information about the Freakonomics chapter about gangs and economics, or try to better understand those living in the projects, this is an awesome listen.
It really changed my attitude about why people live the way they do, why they don't accept help, and why they would turn a blind eye to what I consider appauling behavior. At times I had to walk away for a while to process the information, which is a good thing. It tells me I'm really giving consideration to the book. It took me far outside my comfort zone. At times I loathed the subjects and at other times I wanted to invite them out for coffee. Good job Sudhir. I found JT rather likeable.
The narrator added a grit to the story that made me feel like I was living in the projects. Had I read it myself, it would have been a fluffier story with flowers, puppies, and ice cream in it. The story would have suffered had I read it myself.
I stumbled upon this audio book and remembered the authors name from a chapter in Freakonomics. Since Freakonomics makes my top three books list, I gleefully purchased this book. However I had to listen on commutes, so it took me a couple of days to finish. Good thing too. It gave me time to contemplate the actions of the subjects and change my attitude toward them. (Thank you Sudhir)
So grateful I got to listen to this book. When reading Freakonomics, I always wanted more information. This book deeply satisfied that desire. Delighted Sudhir lived to tell the tale.
This book offers an interesting look at the data gathering process while crafts the kind of stories that I would expect to hear at a really good dinner party. It is not the type of story you would find in the nonfiction section. It is a raw data stream mixed with the light analysis of an academic researcher. I found it exciting and thought provoking.
No but because I wanted to think about what I heard. As a professor myself, I wanted to play with the concepts in my mind that I heard in the book. I was always excited to go back.
I could easily imagine the expressions and emotions of the characters. The author takes us on a journey that few even witness from the outside, much less get to be a part of.
Say something about yourself!
This book was one of my all time favorites. I even got it for my brother to read!
The only negative I could say is that the music in between chapters is a bit much...
I really enjoyed the truth and honesty found in the story. Sudhir captures life in the projects in a way no sociologist has come close to.
I highly recommend it!
Im not an American and dont claim to deeply understand the intricacies of inner city life and race relations but I really enjoyed the book. I was interested in all the characters and felt that I was watching their lives with the author. Excellent !!
Like many, I was introduced to Sudhir Venkatesh's work through Freakanomics. I was expecting a more detailed account of his economic studies but got so much more. The story was fascinating, exciting, funny, and sad. It is a unique look at a part of America that is seldom seen from an intelectual outsiders view. I see a movie in the near future.
If you liked Freakonomics you will love this book. It is a detailed view of a social scientist infiltrating gangs for the sake of knowledge.
Writer, Reader, Former Bookseller (RIP Borders)
I all but took the day off work to listen. It was fascinating, and enjoyable to listen to. I've heard better narrators, but I did not find the reading offensively bad or distracting. It's a terrifying adventure told over the shoulder of a young man with such audacity I was sure he was going to be killed, even though he obviously lived to write the book. Very good. Very much worth the time. Handles a topic with excellence that rarely gets right treatment.
The content of this book is interesting and excellent. But, who cast this narrator? The story is in the first person, and the author is a young, Indian-American grad student. The main characters are young black men. Who decided an older sounding narrator with an aristocratic voice was the best choice to read this book????