"Thought provoking, Heartbreaking"
A story, primarily of one womans life from childhood. The heartbreak and hardships she endured, the friendships formed. A story that kept me hooked and praying for a happy ending. I found the narration difficult to listen to at times, with pauses in the wrong places and at times she sounded like a computer generated voice ! However I got used to it and overall loved this story.
"excellent . Sad, thought provoking, intriguing"
I found this a compelling book and would highly recommend it. I shed a few tears in places.
Read this book some years ago and could not put it down. Changed my thinking about Western involvement in Afghanistan and gave me a thirst for knowledge about this beautiful yet broken country. Passages that haunted me when reading were equally as powerful listening to the narrator.
"One dimensional and lacking insight"
At first I thought the narration was charming. After a while I noticed that she pauses in completely wrong places like someone reading a foreign language or a child learning to read. As I progressed, the narration grated more and more and interfered with listening.
There is no country on Earth I feel more sympathy for than Afghanistan which has suffered decades of torment from cynical manipulators and international bullies. And no-one in Afghanistan deserves more sympathy than its women whose treatment is beyond endurance. This novel follows the lives of two women through the last half century.
I expected it to be fascinating. In the end it was slightly disappointing despite a promising first section. The story is well crafted. As a catalogue of abuse and suffering, and the love and humanity that endures it, it evoked my sympathy and outrage. But the characters were one dimensional, if not formulaic and, it didn't offer any real insight into the political events which wrecked their lives.
Sympathetic as I am to the horror, this is a 3 star novel held down by the narration.
If you are interested in the subject and don't mind reading about a different country, I recommend The Spider's House by Paul Bowles (nicely done on audible), about life in Morocco under French rule. It was so insightful, I felt I reached an understanding of the moslem people, their religion and their customs. Reading it permanently changed the way I think of them.
"Heartfelt moving story"
Narrator was brilliant, great story, eye opening. Definately recommend.
Hope you enjoy as much as i did, have the tissues near by x
"Made a big man cry."
You will live the lives of strong, vulnerable women true lionesses of Afghanistan. I hope they make a film of this soon.
Yes. Makes me realise how lucky we are in the Western world.
It was the realisation that no matter what I thought of the Afghan way before, my vision gave little credence to what it is actually like.
All the women named.
Made me feel very inadequate in my knowledge of Middle Eastern and Islamic ways especially having also read The Kite Runner by the same author.
A book that should be in every school and library
"Beautiful and Inspiring"
The readers voice is brilliant, she interprets the story well with her accents and tone.
I love how it teaches of real life struggles within Afgahnistan
"A wonderful story but tedious narrator"
Yes I like Khaled Hosseini but my enjoyment of the story was spoiled by the monotonous way Atossa Leoni read the story.
Tariq. A kind selfless man
Utterly tedious and really spoiled the story. Admittedly her pronunciation was excellent but her reading of English was stilted and monotonous. She sounded like a computerised voice. Meaning was lost when she failed to read sentences with the correct punctuation and intonation. Rather like somebody picking up the book for the first time without reading the chapters first. This meant that I found it very difficult to sympathise with the characters who all sounded the same.
I would not listen to another book narrated by Atossa Leoni but would happily read another book by Khaled Hosseini.
The story was beautiful and beautifully written. Touching and educative.
The childhood......it is the same all over the world.
The reader was just reading, using pauses where they didn't belong etc.