Speaker, Leader, innovation consultant, kilt-wearer, South African.
I'm a long-time Sherlock Holmes fan and was delighted to discover the complete series here.
The narrator, Charlton Griffin deserves his Audie awards for narration. His performance as Watson is inimitable.
Sadly, Griffin makes some silly mistakes that would have been picked up by any English (not American) producer: For example, in part one he pronounces the word "disconsolate" incorrectly, as well as pronouncing the word "lithe" and "lith," which doesn't make any sense.
The place in London whose name is spelled Streatham is actually pronounced "Strettam" -- something that Griffin and his producers are unaware of.
I'm about three quarters through "The Sign of Four" and some of his pronunciations in that story, littered as it is with Indian English and turn-of-the-century place names are disconcerting.
It mars an otherwise consummate performance of some of the best detective stories in fiction.
Holmes's relationship to his sidekick Watson set the scene for many imitators. I know a woman who has written a thesis on this interplay between the main character and the sidekick -- a relationship which is often more nuanced and deeper than any love interest there may be.
Griffin's characterisation brings these stories to life in a way very different from the printed page. His accents are quite masterful.
It's just a pity he makes those elementary mistakes of pronunciation. Don't let it put you off -- I recommend this edition wholeheartedly.
Absolutely. These are great old detective stories. What's not to like? ;-)
Holmes' intent, direct manner of speaking surprised me at first, but perfectly fit his character.
I have loved Holmes since I was a kid, and hearing these stories again is just fabulous.
I love to read, but my life is so busy that I don't have time for it anymore. Thanks to Audible I can still enjoy my favorite books!
The stories of Sherlock Holmes are both entertaining and intellectually stimulating. From listening to these stories, I have found that both my writing and vocabulary skills have greatly improved.
At the beginning of
I had never heard of Charlton Griffin before. Overall, I was pleased with his performance. He is quite a skilled narrator. He does a wonderful job of distinguishing between the various British accents and his American accents are also quite good. My only issue is that it was often difficult to distinguish between the female characters because many of them sounded the same.
I certainly did WANT to listen to the whole book at once, but I didn't have the time. I tend to listen to my books when I'm at work for the most part, so I saved this one for when I was working and it lasted me a whole three days.
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle is quickly becoming my favorite author of all time!
Carlton Griffin does an amazing job characterizing each character. I never had to wonder who was speaking and at times I had to listen carefully to see if there were different readers. I love Old Time Radio Sherlock Holmes and this is very similar. Great job and the reader has a great voice... I could listen to him read the phone book.
Griffin is the right man for the job of narrating these excellent stories. You're far better off spending a credit on this than watching the Ritchie movie.
The true genius of these works is brought to another level by the narrator Charlton Griffin. His reading is impeccable, and vocal characterizations are masterful. A totally entertaining experience!
I was listening to " A Study in Scarlet" and had thought that I read reached the end of the story and started " The Sign of Four" I got confused with story about a man and a child lost in Idoho and saved by Mormoms then forced to live their way of life. I researched this story and found that it was not the same. After I saw another person review I discovered that this was still "A Study in Scarlet" I rated this low because I thought the download was incorrect. However I found that this is part of A Study in Scarlet after doing some more research.
This is a wonderful series of stories with a narrator that has the ability to bring a listener to another place and time. He is able to keep the different character separate and distinct!
I didn't expect to enjoy these stories, despite the high ratings. When I first loaded my mp3 player, I ignored this book for several days, preferring to listen yet again to two other books I've listened to many, many times (Catching Fire and Mockingjay, vols 2 & 3 of the Hunger Games trilogy).
When I finally decided to see what all the fuss was about, I was very pleasantly surprised! The stories are interest grabbing and the reader is most excellent. Now I must get the rest in this series--and keep my eyes and ears open for the reader.
Reader Charlton Griffen: Wow, you're good!
Pretty good. The narrator does a great job but I'm not as much a fan of Sherlock Holmes as I was hoping I would be. The best story was A Study in Scarlet, but after that I began to lose interest.