Hilarious, engaging, feels like watching the movie for the first time. It might not actually be in my top 5, but I think I've listened to it more times than any other audiobook.
I don't understand the reviews that knock the narrator. I think he does an awesome job. I love his delivery. I was at the gym recently listening to this book for probably the fifth time and it still had me laughing out loud in parts.
Yes, as some of the listeners have pointed out, the narrator's take on the Southern accent was lacking. Luckily, those were a minor character's few lines. The rest he did beautifully-the main character's middle class British, the intonations of his ex-girlfriends, and he especially brought his employees' comical speech to life. I absolutely loved him.
Nick Hornby, of course, is brilliant. A listener commented that this novel is basically about men being pigs. That listener completely missed the point and took the book too literally. This is about how selfish and misguided we all can be in relationships and life-how at our most basic, we all ask-what's in this for me, can I get better? Hornby does this artfully, with British self-deprecating, practical, tongue-in-cheek humor, with great understanding of people and relationships, and with realism. You won't find corny sentimentality here.
This book is filled with fantastic lists (Music, movies, and great loves). Quick and fun read that touches on friendships, passion for music and relationships in a realistic and funny way.
The co-workers in the record shop make the book. The book makes you remember the horrible feelings of breaking up (in a funny way, not depressing) and the unique thoughts you have when that happens. The breaking up phase comes in different stages and this book nails them all.
A good short Sunday read. The movie (same name starring John Cusack and Jack Black) nails the books character and tangents too if you wanted to watch instead of reading it.
The Narrator was bad though...
Listening to Hornby's work is always time well spent. I was disappointed to hear that several good parts were omitted (that's the downside to "abridged").I was stuck in a massive heatwave while visiting relatives in Indiana. Nightly listens to this audiobook helped me forget about the blast furnace outside my hotel window.Next time I'll remember to pack my copy of the book, which I left at home on my nightstand.
I was not the biggest fan of the narrator. Yes, I understand that the book takes place in England (and not Chicago, like the film), but the narrator did the worst job of making up voices for the other characters. He should have just stuck with his own voice instead of holding his nose to create the voices of his fellow record store pals. Don't get me started on his Texas accent...
I love this book completely with one exception....the narrator's "southern drawl" is intolerable. But the good news is that character's appearances are sparse, so its worth suffering through.
part time gourmet, full time nerd
The story is great, very similar to the movie. The narrator is not very enthusiastic and the recording quality is terrible.
Addicted to Audible since 2009
With Cusak and Jack Black, the movie was great but nevertheless, the audiobook was still enjoyable and overall, I thought the narration was really good too.