I hate schlock, and this book is wonderful. Some of the other reviewers have said it quite well, consider this a resounding "yes" to their praise. I can imagine listening to this again some day.
As others have noted, Zafon's own piano score does not help this narration. Davis is a great narrator who does the Spanish impeccably and adds distinctive touches to each character's voice, but when the piano came on I was so distracted. It tends to crank up whenever a woman appears, too, as if we are supposed to take notice of how very ephemeral and mysterious she is. (All his female characters are ephemeral and mysterious.) I hope the producers take note of these comments and consider removing that piano from later editions. I also agree wholeheartedly with the comment to have the physical book on hand (mine was from the library) to keep the characters and especially the POV character straight. When we went into Nuria's POV, I began to get very confused, and even Davis's narration couldn't help me. Otherwise, very enjoyable listen.
I am so glad I experienced this novel as an audiobook! True, there is sometimes too much of a good thing in some of the lengthy descriptions the author uses, but the style fits with the fantasy world of the story. The narrator fits his emotions and pitch with each character and brings them to life, yet still allows the reader to imagine the rest. The icing on the cake is the piano music composed by the author. The notes add texture to what you experience. The flaws in this book are more than made up for by its strengths, earning it 5 stars.
I started reading this book, not remembering much of what it was about. I was immediately captivated by the story line, the wonderful descriptions, and characters. What an adventure. It was hard for me to stop listening!
The narrator, Jonathan Davis, was wonderful; and his depictions of the many characters were flawless. I will be looking for more books authored by Carlos Ruiz Zafon and more books narrated by Jonathan Davis.
This is a truly wonderful book. Terrific storytelling and character development. It is one of those books that yo do not want to end because you enjoy the characters so much. The reader does a great job as well in bringing it to life. I look forward to reading the prequel.
I loved this book when I first read it, and it was also great listening. This is probably one of the best books I've read in years. Beautifully written, suspenseful, wonderful love story set in mysterious Franco era Barcelona. Would recommend for a book club reading.
This is one of those few books that makes you drive the car extra blocks so that you can keep listening. It is multi-layered with plots going deeper and deeper. But it is not hard to follow. The audio production is excellent - the voices clear but with interesting accents. There is a liberal use of music which adds to the already deeply atmospheric book. One of my favorites for a long time. A good story, well produced.
Wonderful as an audiobook, one of my absolute favorites. The narrator does a wonderful job and his performance adds to an already wonderful book. The decision to include music was a real bonus. I highly recommend this one.
this was one of the most beautifully written books I have read in a long time. the writing is almost poetic in places and the story is intruiging and mysterious. there are things to learn all through the book with many turns and twists along the way. did not want this book to end and the narrator was absolutely fantastic. loved this book. enjoy