I really enjoyed listening to this book. The store was unique and the reader was excellent. I highly recommend this book
This is a good book that could have been a better, but I still enjoyed listening to it on a long trip. Very evocative of Spain after the war, and I enjoyed the reader. On the downside, it was very long and sometimes repetitive (perhaps because it's meant for young adults?). And the ending was a disappointment, not really any resolution, from my perspective. still, worth a listen when you want a quiet book to make the time pass.
An interesting plot with some unanticipated turns, it sounds when read, florid and pompous. The reading itself is really quite good. The accent is charming, and the diction and pacing make for a very understandable listen. I suspect the words on the page read well too as a beach paperback, but the combination of the accent and the overwrought/overworked descriptions was simply tiresome. I made it through 2/3 of the story before I just had to move on to something else.
Holy cow. This book seemed interminable from the very first chapter. From the soap-opera music playing in the background the first 15 minutes or so, and the over-wrought, melodramatic prose... I just could not endure this book. First time I ever simply just gave up on a book. Could not take another minute.
The story begins with a 10-year old boy who recently lost his mother. His father lets him in on a "big secret" which, in highly over-dramatized prose, turns out to be nothing more than a book store selling out-of-print used books. Every detail is written as though it were some grand denouement, yet is in most cases mundane and unimportant. The author seems to be on a tear to find the most round-about way to describe the most uninteresting thing. Booorrring. Don't waste your time on this one, honestly.
This is only one of two audio books I have begun and not finished. Out of over a hundred. The story just didn't do a thing for me. It is neither a historical novel or a fantasy. I see in other reviews that some people really liked it. But I just didn't get it. It was long, drawn out and even after half way thru the book I really did not care how it ended so I stopped listening to it.
This may have made a good short story but went on and on about every little thing. I truly do not understand all the good reviews. The author would present some interesting concepts like the secret library; the writer who is a man of mystery; a little coming of age side story, but the interest wanes in all the unnecessary detail. I could not even finish the first part.
This book was recommended by a friend, but after making myself listen to almost 6 hours i finally called it quits because I had tried head from trying to concentrate. Narration is good and the beginning of the book was really interesting but it got very convaluted.
Despite this book's popularity, I found it hard to get into and not much more rewarding as it went along: too many characters were introduced, each telling the same shadowy story again and again, with little point, little individualized character development, weak attempts at humor, little suspense, and no reward for patient efforts at extracting something--anything--of significance from the whole endeavor. The reader tried valiantly to inject some life into the text, but, to my mind, his exaggerated spookiness and odd use of accents only made the whole thing more tiresome.
I kept thinking this story would get better--after all, the basic plot had so much potential, didn't it? A secret library! Well, no real spoilers, but the book--which ended up taking me FOREVER to get through (I almost quit so so many times but kept thinking maybe it would take a turn)--was a whole lot of nothing.
No real story at all. Just a couple interesting characters--and no real story. You keep thinking something interesting will happen--some twist, some connection between all the random pieces--but there is no real mystery, no real wonder, no real anything.
There are enough negative reviews on Amazon that I should've listened to, but I ended up wasting a great deal of time trying to give this story a chance. What a shame.