Dare to dream...
Overall, this was a grueling listen. Mostly a repeat of Band of Brothers, but even so, the book may have held my attention with a good narrator. I simply could not stay focused with the poor narration, and finally quit listening. I will listen to Band of Brothers by Ambrose, again but I'm done with this book.
Oh, you know, stuff.
Yes. There is so much to learn from Major Winter's story about leadership and character that it can't be digested all in one look over.
The description D-Day and D+1 are still fantastic even after having watched and read Band of Brothers. It was great getting to hear about how and why decisions were made, instead of just seeing their results.
He does a pretty good voices for the various men who show up in the story, especially Colonel Sink.
Winter's feeling of responsibility for his men was particularly moving. There are a few times when he talks about things he would have done differently that may have brought home more men, and you can hear the regret and sorrow in his words.
I've listened to this book several times. Since it chronicles the same events as Band of Brothers, it had potential to be tedious, but it is not. It amplifies and clarifies Ambrose's book. It helps you "get into the head" of MAJ Winters.
It is well written and performed. I'm retired Army myself, but I was a "fobbit" -- I rarely had to do anything dangerous. These guys lived with danger, did their jobs and saved the world. I am glad there is a record of their deeds.
Have not read print version
Not sure there is one. Dick Winters was a superb soldier and human being.
Each character has his own identity and feeling about him.
To digest it takes time.
This book should be mandatory reading for all officers in the military. They would learn more about leadership than from any manual. I wish I could have read it when I was a Lieutenant.
Being an avid follower of Stephen Ambroses books and as such having read Band of Brothers many times as well as watching the series twice a year since release, I loved this book because while there were sections that were in the book (Band of Brothers), there was so much more detail about the life of the late Dick Winters, especially in the lead up to D-Day and after his time in the 506 PIR.
This firsthand account from one of the finest combat officers of the war, is more than worth the read, or listen. Those of you who saw or read Band of Brothers may find some of it redundant...however, it is direct from the man who led Easy Co. at Normandy through the Holland campaign, and eventually led 2nd Bn. 506th PIR through VE day. Leaders like Maj. Winters are few and far between...I highly recommend this heartfelt memoir. Very inspiring. Excellent reader.
An insightful enhanced look at what we now all know to be the "Band of Brothers". But I do think Mr. Weiner was the wrong choice for Mr. Winters' memoirs. He has a fine voice, and is certainly capable, but seemed to relish opportunities to display a French accent and was too over-the-top when quoting other characters, which mis-represents Mr. Winters.
I am nit-picking this, but it was a distraction to listen to.
This reviews much of the story told in the Band of Brothers. There isn't much new. Winter's personal perspective is interesting. He is as straight-laced an individual as is portrayed in the HBO movie.