Maybe if I had unlimited time and patience I could have stuck it out, but after over an hour of listening it was too frustrating. I couldn't understand what was going on, who was talking or even when it was conversation. The narrator was annoying because he over-acted.
Without a clear understanding of all the intrigues of Henry VIII, I found this book very hard to follow and understand.
I gave it several hours, but it just did not hold my attention.
Although the narrator gets good reviews, I found many of his voices to be so similar that I wasn't sure who was talking.
I always love to read about the intrigue of the British monarchy but this is too hard to follow.
My husband is reading this book on his IPad and I am listening to it on my IPad. We both find it hard to follow because the different characters are not easily identified when they are speaking - more the style of writing than the fault of the reader.
There's been a great deal in recent media about Henry VIII and Ann Boleyn, and I thought I'd heard and read enough to last me a lifetime. But I heard Hilary Mantel interviewed on Fresh Air and she sounded so intelligent and spoke in such an interesting way about the women in her books, that I thought I'd given them a try. Lucky me! I learned more than I could have imagined about the people who played their large and tragic parts in the drama of Henry and Ann. But this is a book about Thomas Cromwell in particular--only a name to me until now. Fascinating and wonderful read/listen! You won't be disappointed.
DALE reader one
I liked it but....
Ah too bad it's over but what exactly was I listening too
I think so. His voice was neat
The is the point since there were so many. The characters seemed scrabbled
Maybe if the author had set the tone much closer to the bone and then from tim to time come in deeply with the characters talking it would have been better. Mind you I didn't dislike it,but.....left a bit to be desired
This is one of the best audiobooks I've listened to because it's such a fascinating, well-written literary achievement. Although exploring the mind and character of Thomas Cromwell, it has much to say to us today about the uses of political power and the clash of government and religion. The book's great strength is giving readers/listeners the view from inside Cromwell's mind---a very intelligent place to be. Hilary Mantel certainly deserved the Booker Prize for this book.
Simon Slater captures a vast number of characters with his powerful and nuanced narration and he rendered perfectly the humanity and fierce intelligence of Thomas Cromwell, making me realize once again that audiobook narration is a high art that should be honored as such. I like Simon Vance too, but I wonder why Slater is not the narrator on the follow-up book to Wolf Hall, Bring Up the Bodies. In any case, I'll look for Slater's work in the future and I'm grateful to have this one.
I MADE A HUGH ERROR IN PARAGRAPH 3. IT'S PATRICK, NOT PETER. MEA CULPA!!!
It is equal to my copy of Gustav Flaubert's "Madame Bovary", Mantel being one of the greatest writers of our time.
"Wolf Hall" has a lyrical and deadly style. Ms. Mantel does not, for once, portray Thomas Cromwell as an inky, little slacker, but a full-bodied thinking man of the 21st Century.
What moved me the most was Cromwell's tender memories of his lost girls, and his steel eyed interrogation of Thomas More.
Best book I've had in decades!
It would be difficult to recommend any changes because it earned the Booker Prize. That is a very intimidating award.
Thomas Cromwell has always intrigued me, but I got tired of him...I am not so intrigued any more
He was the only reason I kept trying to like the book.
Well, I don't plan to invest the time finishing it.
Even with Mr. Slater's skills,I i was often baffled about who was talking and what/who they were talking about. This is sometimes a disadvantage in any book with the audio format, as I can't flip back the pages. That said, I probably wouldn't have had the patience to go back and forth in the book, either.
Host of CraftLit and Just-the-Books podcasts, editor of What Would Madame Defarge Knit? series, mother of boys, knitter of things, teacher of stuff...
One of the best audiobooks I've heard (and I've heard many). There is something inexorable about the movement of this book and this narrator (actually... both Simon Slater and Thomas Cromwell). Something to which we must attend. Something which cannot be denied... and I'm not alone in this, I know.
Hilary Mantel has done such a service to history, it just makes me want to hug the book.
I love the way he growls at the passage of time.
His voice is... very Cromwell-appropriate. It matches his attitude and his life's-story so nicely... while Simon Vance (Bring up the Bodies) does a fine job, his reading suffers by comparison (no fault of his own) bc Slater is so iconically suited to this part.
If there is a God, s/he will allow Slater to record Bring up the Bodies and all Mantel/Cromwell books which follow...
Cromwell... but I'd want to be sure there was plenty to drink at the dinner. _I_ would need it... I doubt he would.
The narrative is odd-ish, sure. Mantel's work here is very different from what you'd expect form a Tudor-iffic story... but Slater's voice and Mantel's genius merge here in a grand way to make you ache for a time machine.
I would definitely try another Hilary Mantel book. I think she is a talented author. This book would be a good reading book, where where the words would get processed. I struggled to keep up with this story because I was constantly trying to figure out who was talking, what was said and where and when was the narration taking place.
I felt like I needed to know the story and characters well in order to truly appreciate this story. I watched "The Tudors" so I had some knowledge of the history, but I was still lost.
OK, but a difficult book to read because there are so many characters. It was difficult to tell who was talking. And the narration was fast so by the time I might have figured out who was talking, I had missed the essence of what they had said.
disappointment because I like period literature, but this seemed like a bunch of jumble.