I would remove all the 2nd person stuff. It's off-putting and presumptuous; a lot of unnecessary conjecture and supposition about the inner feelings of the band and those connected to it. It also pulls the reader out of time since these are often flashbacks. I was always pleased when the narrator returned to the main thread.
I haven't read many of these types of rock bios in recent years, but I listened to Clapton's autobiography and found it similar, in that there were interesting parts when the music being made was great and popular, and then a long epilogue where the author has to gloss over a few boring and repetitive decades subsequent to the peak era.
Thought he did a great job, and I appreciated his shifting accents, even though I did not like the book's choice to use 2nd person perspective in those parts.
To re-listen to the later Led Zeppelin albums, and Robert Plant's later work.
I did not think the occult emphasis in the book was out of place, as other reviewers might. Jimmy Page and his ideas/beliefs are the heart of Led Zeppelin's music, so all of that was entirely relevant, as those ideas seemed to shape his life in the 1970s. It was educational and of interest.
Most of these long bios tend to drag at the end, and while I was looking forward to hearing about the post-breakup period, it did seem to get bogged down and repetitive. The author gets brutally critical of the band members after LZ's peak around 1975, not totally without reason, but it's a bit jarring considering the praise he lavishes on each member before that.
There's also a tendency in these bios, and this is no exception, to neatly summarize people and their histories as if they are fictional characters instead of complex real people, in a desire to make a book's ending more satisfying. Jimmy Page comes off at the end as someone desperately clinging to the legacy of his band, as if he is "haunted by demons." It's a spooky way to characterize and close out the author's themes, but the real man seems more complex than that. The biographer paints a selfish and controlling picture of Plant by the end, and never seems quite sure how to talk about John Paul Jones, as a great musician who was key to the band, or someone more deluded and inconsequential.
But regardless, I'm glad I listened, I learned a few things, and the book has a good amount of detail, only regrettably interrupted in terms of chronology by the aforementioned second person accounts.
“A reader lives a thousand lives before he dies…The man who never reads lives only one.” (George R. R. Martin)
I thought Mick Wall’s bio of Led Zeppelin was quite good and I burned through the 18 hours very quickly. I have been a Zeppelin fan since junior high and have always been looking for a decent biography of the band but could just never find one. Finally, (many) years later here it is. I’m no Zeppelin aficionado. There are definitely fans out there who know much more about the band than I do but neither am I a casual fan. I was always intrigued by the occult mystique that surrounded the band and Mick Wall goes into great detail trying to shed light on this aspect. I learned a lot of new information about the band and the listen was highly entertaining.
I definitely recommend this audio book for readers/listeners who are interested in the band or in tales of rock and roll history. Much of the book is fascinating and brings a lot of detail about the creative process and the experience of rock and roll. It is also satisfying in the way it follows up into the present day.
However the book also has it's silly side, especially in the constant harping on satanism, and the repetition--especially in the arty 2nd person flashback scenes to the musicians early lives. These flash backs grow old very very quickly.
The narrator is brilliant; making this an extremely good audio book experience; making it easy to get past the sillier parts of the book!
Pros: A decent history of the band full of all the necessary highlights. Cons: The flashback sequences are painfully awkward and all over the place chronologically really messing up the whole flow of the book. I don't feel they added anything, and they all have the same tone as if the 4(+Grant) members were the same person. Also, this is essentially a Jimmy bio through the first 2/3 of the book, the other members are virtually ignored and their contributions feel lessened. Lastly, the book is rather objective until it hits the epilogue where it is full of scathing comments and some very harsh words. The change in style is jarring.
I'm a huge Zepp fan and couldn't wait to listen to this book, but just made it through one hour and I'm done. All of the references in the 2nd person are just way to painful to endure. No idea why the author wrote the book that way, makes it impossible to listen to.
Canceling Sirius and getting an Audible subscription was a great move for me. I love to read and now can keep up with all my favorite books while I am working out, driving my car, or as a bedtime story. Sure, I am in my 40’s, but you are never too old for a bedtime story.
The Narrator was horrible as were the 2nd person references.
Accent was off-putting as was the continuous 2nd person reference.
Avoid at all costs.
I was one of the first Zeppelin fans when they first found a name for themselves back in the 60's I was really looking forward to the book but I really did not find it that exciting. It was okay and there were some interesting things in it but it wasn't one of those books that you just can't put down.
I am a Christian but I have a pretty good tolerance for a little smut here and there but this book starts off too sexually explicit from the get-go and so I bagged it.