A good story poorly read! Bernard Cornwells description of the Battle of Trafalgar is excellent. His ability to describe the battle scene and the thoughts of the combatant involved are unequaled. In this book, the 4th in the series, it appeared to me to take too long to get the main battle. There was a lot of filler waiting for something to happen. It may be on purpose as a 3 month sail back home would be quite boring. Once the battle started, Bernard Cornwell was a good as I have read.
I was very disappointed with Patrick Tull's reading of the book. He sounds like a baptist minister with a British Accent. In many spots of the book, he sounded like he had marbles in his mouth. I lost many words and sometimes thoughts because I found his speach difficult to listen to. It was the only real disappointment in this excellent book.
Haven't read the print version. The whole idea of ordering from Audible is to enjoy books through my EARS - - not to compare/contrast editions.
Cornwell's usual combination of history and fiction.
Patrick Tull tries to (does?) lend an air of legitimacy to "British English" - and even "British English as spoken by British sea men - and, in so doing, renders his reading totally unintelligible in some (too many) passages. His accent becomes incapable of understanding by an American ear and he drops volume below what it audible when listening in an automobile. (Mine would be considered a luxury vehicle by anyone's standards and, still, there was this problem.)
I would NOT make a film of this book. It would cost WAY too much and would not have a large audience.
Part 2 of this book is missing a large chunk at the beginning. I have compared this to my local public library's print book and book on tape. I believe that Audible needs to fix this as this seems to me simply a technical error and not an issue of "abridged" vs. "unabridged". This is a defective item pure and simple and subscribers should not be charged for a defective item.
Otherwise I agree that Patrick Tull is often difficult to understand as a narrator. I consider this one of the weaker Sharpe novels but they are all enjoyable nonetheless.
The story was great but the reader was uninspiring and the accents he used particularly Sharpe, he made Sharpe sound unconvincing.
The story is great, love the change where Sharp is on a sea voyage and sea battles, but the narration leaves something to be desired.
The recording as much as the narrator is just low quality. Voice goes from low to high and there is no happy medium. Turn up the volume and the volume hurts when the narrator raises the voice, turn it low and you cant hear the quiet parts.
I wish this book is re-recorded.
I was engaged through the entire book. There was lots of action, romance and courage under fire. The story is complex and holds-on throughout book.
Sharpe's Rifles compares very well to this episode of Sharpe's series. Both books can keep your attention and entertain you wanting more.
I find Patrick Tull's reading performance very comfortable, exciting and enjoyable to listen to. When you think about the time you are granting to the performer into your ear Patrick Tull is a great choice.
I was not able to sit and listen all at once, I was able to allow enough time over three days.
if Cornwell's goal was to bore us as much as the passengers on a four month cruise from India to Britain then I'd say this book was rather successful, but I seriously doubt that was his objective. In other books Sharpe is a dark hero but in this he is
nothing but an adulterous murderer, why?
The reading of this book was annoying at best. Why Mr. Tull wouldn't have read it in his own and then added character voices is beyond me. Instead he read it in a shrill voice that went up and down to where at times I could barely hear him and at others he nearly deafened me.
All and all, two stars is being generous
Once again, Cromwell is marvelous. His characters are always so intriguing and developed to just the right degree. Any less and you wouldnt buy into them. Any more and and the story would drag and the characters would become less interesting, something about familiarity breeding contempt. Im a fan both of Cromwell and of Patrick Tull as well. I discovered Mr. Tull when listening to O'Briens Master and Commander. Each of his characters is so unique. I cant wait to start Sharpes Prey.