Nelson DeMille bases this book on a long debated theory that living POW's have been transported to Russia rather than being returned home to America. I have read about this and debated it with military people that I know and still am not sure. But as far as the basis for a novel it makes an interesting story. I was lucky, as I am not qualified to judge the validity of the military events in the story but it is a story. And with Scott Brick reading it what a story it is!
It moves a bit slow in the beginning, but it's really background info that will come in handy later, by the middle when you have a better grip on who these people are or might be the plot begins to coil up tighter and by the end you are sliding down a roller coaster at mach 1 with some surprises you never saw coming. Another great read by Scott Brick because he times the reading with the plot. It left me wondering about Russia and the way living there for several years changes people, for it most certainly does.
I recently listened to Word of Honor and was hoping for a story of the same caliber. I thought this book would come close but apparently I should have read more reviews. It starts off good and indeed Demille is an amazing writer but there was so much propaganda I had to keep reminding myself it was written during a time when the Russians really were considered totally evil and we just couldn't say enough bad things about them. It's kind of two dimensional in that respect but there was still information about Russian life that was interesting and informative. Sometimes I would almost laugh at Scott Brick's narration. I wonder to myself--Doesn't anyone edit this stuff?? There were several times when Mr. Brick tried to put so much feeling into his narration that he sounded like he was going to start to cry, usually when someone was on a rant about the morality of the west vs. the east.
But the thing that really disappointed me was the ending. It was almost like the writer's story was hijacked by his jealous brother who set out to completely sabotage the novel with a ridiculous ending that just went on and on. I didn't even finish the last 40 minutes of the story. I just didn't care what happened to any of them.
The last twenty per cent of the story pretty much ruined the story for me and left me wishing I had chosen another book.
As a person with dyslexia, audio books give me the opportunity to "read" wonderful books that I would otherwise miss. Thank you for this fabulous service.
I was telling a friend that I had just read Child 44 set in 1953 Russia. I mentioned a show I had seen on PBS years ago called Sleepers about a couple of embedded Russian agents in the UK who had been forgotten. My friend said I had to read The Charm School. I have never read a Nelson DeMille book before, but I certainly will look up some of his others.
I had to check to see when the book was written to get a better orientation to the time and place. The writing was good, the characters were interesting. I'm not a fan of Scott Brick but he did a decent job on this book.
The only quibble I have with the book is the standard male fantasy of the 29-year-old woman and the mid-forties age man. I'd like to see a story like this where the ages were reversed.
I wondered how the story was going to be resolved. Nice job of that, though I felt a small bit of dissatisfaction at the very very end. But up to that point, I was on the edge of my seat. Very entertaining and I would recommend.
I am a rabid fan of spy novels and I don't write many reviews. However, I have to say, this book was so terrible that I felt I must warn other readers. When I bought the book I expected a lot given its high ratings. However, it disappointed on a number of accounts. First of all, half the book is blustery diatribe about the former Soviet Union and the nature of the Russian people. A little of this would be OK to add context to the story, but it is overwhelming and completely bogs down the plot. Second of all, the characters are quixotic and often make irrational decisions which are not consistent with either their previous behavior or their personalities. Lisa Rhodes in particular is probably one of the worst drawn female protagonists I have read. There were several times while listening when I said out loud, "Oh shut up you idiot!". The narrator too is sub-par. I have listened to many books narrated by Scott Brick. The guy has only one tone of voice and he often adds sarcastic inflections at inappropriate points. Give me George Guidall over him any day. Finally, the grand finale, a great rescue attempt, is ridiculous strategically. I don't want to spoil it for you poor souls who shoulder through the 24 hours of listening time, but lets just say that if you think about it for more than a minute, you realize that neither the US military nor the CIA would ever plan or enact such a hair-brained scheme. Honestly, I can't believe I wasted a whole day of my life listening to this.
I love DeMille's books and this is another winner. The Charm School starts out a little slow but once it gets going, it cannot be put down. A great read that I would highly recommend.
Since this book appears to be a pre 9/11, cold war type book, I thought it would come across as dated. It was excellent.
DeMille has a knack for showing us the subtleties of a different ways people live and survive. This book showed Soviet cold war living in the same way Up Country showed the living in Viet Nam 20 years after America pulled out.
On top of that is an incredible story,
I am not sure if it was a man reading female dialog, but the main female character seemed very stupid and listening to her really got on my nerves. If you can tune her out, the book would be about 3 and 1/2 stars. If it wasn't for the very dark subject matter and charaters, I would have given this 4 stars. If you like spy stories and don't mind depressing subject matter, I think you will like this book. I don't usually read spy genre, but really enjoyed that aspect of this book.