The author does exactly what he started out to do: Ignore the facts and slander WalMart with distortion and sleight of hand. This book will give more fuel to the Wal Mart haters because to them, like the author, facts are irrelevant. To be sure, Wal Mart has made mistakes in how it has treated its employees, sometimes violating labor laws. For that, they should be, and have been, fined and made to work within the confines of the law.But to be hated simply because of their size and perceived influence is just one more bit of evidence how progressives hate the rich and powerful. Unless of course your a rich and powerful liberal (see George Soros).To make this a 4 or 5 star book, the author could have simply reported on the facts without consistently adding negative commentary that really only revealed his pettiness. The author starts the book by revealing a story of a Wal Mart success. Wal Mart was the impetus for deodorant manufacturers ceasing to package their plastic and metal deodorant products inside cardboard boxes. By all accounts, it was a wonderful idea. Less weight when shipping, less waste in landfills, fewer forests cut down to make the boxes. But none of these positives can detract from the fact that the guy who sold the cardboard lost business. This is the theme throuought the book. No matter what positives Wal Mart contributes, the author is not even a glass half empty guy. No, the glass is dry!
Very entertaining, well written, and easy to listen to. Kept my interest throughout the entire book. The newly update afterward by the author was a delightlful surprise.
all this crap about buying cheap and having to assemble.. geez have NEVER purchased a BBQ grill that I didn't have to assemble so that example was CRAP!! amongst about most of the rest in this book. talk about making comparisons that weren't. so deceiving!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
a few other reviewers thought it was lopsided or poor on economic theory. But thought it was as fair as it could be with the information present. It was worth a listen.
Though I'm interested in these types of books T felt there was a little too much detail. This is one case where I would have preferred the abridged version. This is the first book that adjusted the speed to Faster on my iPod. the author says he was critical to Walmart but more often I felt like he an advocate for Walmart.
This book blew me away. I've shopped at Wal-Mart for years and am a "conflicted" buyer. Although I've had doubts about my Wal-Mart experiences in terms of conflict of conscious, this book distilled those chaotic thoughts into coherent logic. I have a lot to think about especially from a socially responsible point of view. The book is easy to understand and very well written.
This is a good informative book. It does not seem to be biased in any way, but does provide very interesting insights into the workings of Walmart. I liked it.
Reading this book I recalled a professor who in the 60's claimed Sears was destroying America. Big attracts such comments. I was hoping for discussions of cross docking and collaborative planning and forecasting and other supply chain innovations that Wal-Mart used to create an advantage. Instead it was 75% bashing. Big is evil.