Drama teacher and Sci-Fi/Fantasy fan
Orson Scott Card tells great stories. But this recording picked a horrible reader for the character of Reverend Thrower. The semi-dramatized nature of the recording works well for the tale, but the actor who portrays the Thrower chapters can't decide if he wants to use a Scottish burr or not.
I really like Orson Scott Card books. REALLY lilke them. But this one just never seemed to go anywhere. Most of the characters are not likable and you don't really care what happens to them. I will probably read the next one for the same reason I picked up this one.....to see what the hype is about. I certainly didn't find my answer in this book.
In the Afterwards the author says that this story was originally supposed to be a trilogy but he is now making it seven books with the last one being multi-thousand pages. I think he should have stuck with his original plan. The story line is plodding and you can only hear about the colonial life so much before you want to scream to get on with it.
I might have finished this story line if it were a trilogy but thinking of having to listen to six more books meandering along is more than I can take.
I liked this one, but after I moved on to the 2nd and 3rd....I don't know.
I know this is fiction and loosely based on some american history. Being an african american, it is kind of hard to listen to the imaginative world where it's ok to slaughter, rape, kill, and sell people to delevope the west. Even though I know those things happened.
It's still clasic Card. You decide.
I have been a fan of OSC since I first listened to the book Enders Game. From there I listened to the rest of that series, now after this book as well I'm of the opinion OSC is a religious author. I wish he would right fantasy or science fiction and simply leave out "Religion". I find it humorous that in his books with the religion he writes in it that he shows those supporting it and others saying its not right to force upon others the beliefs or religion of those that practice or beliefs said topic. But yet in writing his stories he does exactly that which he writes isn't correct. Oh well just a thougt.... Still OSC is capable of writing a entertaining and enjoyable story as he has proved time and again, just be warned that you must keep an open mind when reading it or it could easily offend.
More of a western than a fantasy novel
The narration was good but It could not make the story more interesting
I will probably have to listen to this book again before I can give are better review.
Discovered audio books as a way to pass the time at work and now I'm hooked.
Yes, it does a great job of tying facts into a historical fiction.
Yes, I think they would enjoy some of the parodies to real history.
The different personalities.
No, I don't think anyone would want to make this into a movie.
I read this series some years ago and loved it. The story is well told in this audio book and I
am enjoying listening to it over and over again.