...I loved the book so much that I am going to Gettysburg this fall...I could not put the book down...The part where the boys form Maine had to "Fix Bayonets" was unbelievable ...I can't imagine how those boys felt charging with empty rifles into the incoming enemy...Well written...They don't hand out Pulitizer Prizes to any book....Well worth reading....
I could not get into this book. I did not connect with the commanders, and I did not feel much of what Shaara was trying to convey with the dialogue. I did like some of the battle descriptions, particularly those involving Chamberlain. But overall, I feel this book did not live up to the hype.
I really struggled to get to the end of this book. The reader is inconsistent with the voices he uses for different characters. He also spends a good portion of his reading in a wavering, far off, remorseful southern accent. It just gets irritating and slows down the pace of the book considerably. Plus reading Robert E. Lee with a sleepy Scarlet O'Hara voice should be some sort of crime. Great writing. Get a new narrator.
The book is decent. Fells slow to begin with epically if you know the history of the civil war. The book is very detailed and enjoyable. The narrator takes a bit to get used to though.
I have listened to several books, this is the best I've heard. The articulation in the narrators voice, and the use of different voices for each character was amazing. I even shed a tear at one point. It really put a human touch on 150 yr old history. Loved it.
Exceptional rendering of the men who valiantly served for both the union and the confederacy at Gettysburg. An interpersonal depiction of the character of certain individuals - high and low in rank - in their hopes, fears and gut-wrenching service in the face of death. I felt it was like being along side of each of them in battle. A Pulitzer prize winner that touched my heart and awakened my awareness of a time when men were defined by their the strength of their word and love of their countrymen .
I enjoy counter-terrorism, westerns, historical fiction, detective mysteries, and old school comedy like "A Christmas Story".
I never imagined history could be not only educational but also exciting and enjoyable to absorb. Thank you Michael Shaara for making Civil War history come to life for me!
I have read the book, and know the history, but this rendition brings the story to life. The book is a classic, and the narrator is fantastic. This is a must listen!!
The most interesting part of this audiobook is the first 5 minutes, in which the author's son tells the story of his father's quest to write and publish this book. Unfortunately, the narrator of the actual book made it a classic bore. After the first hour or two, I finally gave up. It just failed to capture my imagination the way an audiobook usually does. Too bad there are no used audiobook shops. I would trade this one in immediately.
A very enjoyable look inside the minds of the commanders of the armies that fought at Gettysburg. Excellent narration.