There is no way to say how bad this book is - just awful! No history and completely anachronistic characters. I was tricked by the good reviews - one has to cross reference the good reviewers to see what other books those people liked. The narration is really bad too - hyper dramatic. Yuck.
Kathleen in FL
I was never absolutely sure if this was totally fictional or had a historical basis. Even hearing the epilogue made me wonder if some of the story might have been true. I was caught up in the novel.
The narrator was excellent.
I would recommend this book.
I have given up on an audiobook only two or three times out of hundreds downloaded. This was one. This book is so full of sterotype and cliche that it made me gag.
is a writer's golden rule Jim Fergus did not learn. His premise is interesting. The language and tone of the "letters" are authentic. However, a long list of stock characters (the big ugly cheerful immigrant woman, the Irish rouges, the queenly black former slave woman) destroys the novel's masquerade as a true account. It is tedious and predictable, and when Mr. Fergus slides into soft pornography, he abandons his pretense completely.
So many books, so little time. NO time for this one.
I have an undergraduate degree in philosophy and a Master's Degree in Professional Writing from Maharishi University of Management, am author of THE RELUCTANT VEGETARIAN COOKBOOK, and am an avid reader/listener.
This book is haunting, literally. The memories of it lingers with me like people I've lived with and loved, and for whom I mourn in the same sense I mourned President Kennedy and Martin Luther King Junior. I believe May Dodd's cosmic purpose was to communicate to us truth of life with the Native Americans, and for a past now destroyed. It is a record, a memorial unlike anything I've ever read (listened to). I can't begin to explain all the reasons for loving this book, but I certainly loved the quality of the writing, the authenticity of the writing, and the depth of each character. Certainly they are the most fascinating characters you'll meet anywhere. At first I thought they were so unique that this must be a work of fiction, but then I realized that the very nature of the circumstances would have called forth such fascinating eccentrics. By the end of the book, I felt like I had experienced every emotion in the world, with love being one of the most predominate.
In the book CAPTURED, there is a collection of stories about children who were abducted by Native Americans and it was fascinating to read about how many of them, recaputured by the Whites, did not want to stay but to be returned to their Native American families. But it wasn't clear WHY they preferred Native Americans. I think this book explains it.
During my childhood, "Indians" were characterized as all bad, i.e., "The only good Indian is a dead Indian." Other books or movies such as DANCES WITH WOLVES, the Native Americans are romanticized as all good. But in this book, the stark, frank realism explains both sides with writing that made me thrill with appreciation, and to feel like I too was one of those women living their hard but satisfying life, and it explained to me why, given a choice, one would choose to remain with them. If this is an authentic journal as claimed, it iis certainly a national treasure. I long to see it made into a movie.
Good God! This term seems to be common among the author's writing (and among the other characters so it must have been a term of the day). But that one term might serve as a measure for Hick's ability to understand the events in the journal. At one point I recall thinking that she must have some depth of character of her own in order to read with the full range of emotions called forth by this story--everything from love to horror.
May Dodd was obviously intelligent, well educated, and highly articulate, as well as being admirably strong in character. She would be fascinating in any society.
This is a great story and could not quit listening. The characters were great and real. I laughed and cried.
Lots of people seem to love this book - it depends on your taste. To me the characters were embarrassingly simple and predictable. How can a rich, spoiled white woman in 1875 think like a modern, liberal woman? The book would have made more sense if May started out with some of the attitudes of her class and upbringing, then over time learned that she was being biased and unfair. This book will not challenge you to think. The reader was good, doing her best with poor material. I wish Audible had a category for chick lit. I would like some kind of way to avoid these books, other people must be searching for them. Occasionally I buy one by mistake. It was a waste of a credit.
the story captured my interest and kept me listening. okay, so its a bit far fetched at times but it is supposed to be entertainment, and if you read it as such, it was a good book.
I enjoyed the book on a plot level to some degree but found the smattering of female characters underdeveloped and trite. I wouldn't recommend this one.