Love a great book that stays with you long after you've finished it.
I expected the everyday details between the white women and the Native Americans these women had chosen to marry as their lives moved forward. Instead there is not much conversation at all in this book, context is taken from "journals" written by one of the woman. There were some dramatic moments, funny situations and characters that made me laugh, it is just too bad more character development or time was not spent to make the novel much more interesting. I would start to care about certain characters, but then the story would curve and we would never hear much about that person again. The novel seemed very unrealistic, and as if it had huge holes in it. I would not recommend it.
While I think the premise of the story was good, it was obvious to me that in parts it was a man's fantasy imagining a woman's fantasy which I found a little insulting.
This book is an okay listen. The main character annoyed me with her superior attitude. She was always the best, the prettiest, the wittiest, the toughest....the best at everything. You also wonder which parts of this story are "historic" and which ones are "fiction." I think that what they say about an Indian leader going to Washington to offer this deal is true, but some were even questioning if that part even happened. It is interesting to listen to and if one narrator read this which I think she did, then she did a great job with voices/accents. You want to keep reading to see what happens to these women once they marry the Indian tribe members. It is a good book. Nothing to write home about. Not super eloquent,but entertaining.
I listened because my book club selected it but it was a pleasant surprise...engaging, would recommmend it. The cowboys vs the indians from another point of view...
All I can say is that I am from those white women. I grew up in Nebraska. I was surprised there was no mention of the rattle snakes. They were always all over the place. It is such a rugged territory. Back then, just as the book says, it was "uncivilized". No porta-potties." anywhere to be seen.
I am grateful to have spent my youth there. I am now 65 years old. This book did, indeed help me to know and understand , not only my own beginnings, but how the United States came to be. Not all of it swathed in honor.
Thanks, a good book and a good listen.
The continuing theme appears to be "American white women are feisty, gritty and capable; American Indians are quiet, strong and mostly not savage." The story in this book revolves around the journal of a 19th century white woman who escapes a mental institution (where she has so very unjustly been incarcerated) and joins a dozen or so other hearty-adventurer women to become wives of "savages" and bring them into the warm arms of "civilization" through the children they will bear with them. Got that? While accomplishing these not-small tasks this young woman also keeps (through storm, attacks, vagabond treks) a very detailed journal (of course, because how could we have this story without it) written in everlasting-pencil. Okay, I admit I found this a bit over the edge of believability, but even though I was incredulous, I was interested enough to persevere and finish this book. I decided (after the decision that the book is unbelievable fiction) that I was enjoying the story. I like science fiction sometimes, too, and never need to think it is believable, so why not historical fiction? There we have it again - a book I rate at three stars just 'cause it was a darned good story.
Don't waste your time. I gave it one star because they won't let you give zero stars. I read this book because it was this month's book for our book club. When we met it was clear that no one enjoyed it and even the person who had suggested it to the club was perplexed as to why it was highly rated. It is more like a romance novel, and not a good one at that, than an historical fiction. The writing was weak. He had limited descriptive range, for example, every time he talks about an indian they are "nut brown" and one character is always "a sight to behold" There was no subtlety.
I wouldn't even take this one as a beach read
the book was not. This could have been an interesting historical novel. It was written like a bad romance with unlikely characters. There is an unusual amount of repitition of scenes and lines. I couldn't decide if it was poor writing or poor editing. Definitly not for anyone interested in the history of Native Americans.
Well written from the perspective of a strong female.
Both did an excellent job of reading and performing.
I wish I could have read it all in one setting...the read was so engaging.
This was one of my favorite audible purchases.
Mae's story was incredible. How could she not be the favorite character?
Laura did a wonderful job bringing the characters to life. Nice flow and excellent job in accents.