I like that Roy Dotrice gets into the story and uses different voices for diferent characters; however, I had a hard time with his thick English accent, especially at first. Also, his female characters tend to sound like old hags, and there's one character in particular that I can hardly understand. Roy Dotrice sounds like he is talking past a mouth full of food and mumbling at the same time when narrating this character. I can understand theatrics and all, but this is a book, not a movie. I hate having to rewind the storry several times to understand what a character is saying. A narrator is supposed to bring the story alive, not destroy with overdone theatrics. If I were reading this story, instead of listening to it, I would be able to understand the character perfectly. I should be able to when I'm listening to it as well. Minus 2 stars because of Roy Dotrice's inconsiderate narration.
Massively intricate world with well developed characters.
That's impossible, at least for me.
This series has a lot of characters that are hard to keep straight at first. I've read the book twice before getting the audio version so I knew who was who.
This story takes a while to get going, but the characters are pretty interesting and complex. I like that no one is pure good or evil.
I know it's a series, but I didn't like the way the book just ended. It just seemed like a big set up for the next book. I'm used to stories having more of an ending, even if there are larger overall story arcs that span multiple books. I enjoyed the story and will probably go on to the next one, but I felt like the author kind of left me hanging.
I thought the narrator did a great job. Any one that can do that many characters, with that great of age differences has fantastic range.
If you know before starting that this first book doesn't really complete a story arc, then you'll enjoy it quite a bit.
First off, I'm not a huge reader. I'm an extremely slow reader and I don't have very good reading retention. Not to mention the fact that I don't have a ton of time to read and can't read while on the plane or in the car because of motion sickness. But I do enjoy listening to a good audiobook while on plane flights, long car rides, eating lunch at my desk, laying in bed at night or even just mowing the lawn. I enjoy a great narrator who is an excellent voice actor and I even enjoy the productions with music and sound effects. I compare audiobooks to the radio plays of the 1920's, 30's and 40's.
Prior to listening to this book I had heard from several of my friends and read numerous reviews about how good this collection of books was. I had watched the first season of the HBO series "Game of Thrones" and I enjoyed it thouroughly so figured I would go ahead and give the books a try.
I love the story and the writing style. The description of the characters, what their thinking, the plotlines, drama, conflicts and action. I enjoy an audiobook even more when the narrator does voices for each individual character. That's the love part of the review.
Hate may be too strong of a word for the rest the review. Dislike might even be too strong. I'm not a fan of Dotrice as a narrator (acting is a different story). I can tolerate him, but he in no way matches the likes of two of my favorite narrators, Mark Thompson or Jim Dale. A lot of the voices that Dotrice does are extremely similar. With other narrators, no two voices are alike. As one of the other reviewers put it, even the female characters (including the young girls) sound like 70 or 80 year old men sometimes. Some of the inflections that he uses when reading the lines make the conversations between characters seem extremely dry and emotionless. But again, I can tolerate it and he doesn't completely ruin the book for me. Afterall, I'm listening to it because I don't want to read it.
One of the other things that bugs me about this audiobook is the chapter splits seem to be way off. I downloaded the files straight to my iPod using the Audible app. When listening to the file, the chapter splits appear to be in the middle of a conversation. Then throughout the chapter, there appear to be natural breaks which would seem to be the actual chapter break. I don't know if this is just a problem with the files on my iPod and the chapter breaks got screwed up somehow when I downloaded it or if the original files on the Audible server are incorrect.
Outstanding narration really brought the story, characters to life! Roy Dotrice voice is incredible! Have passed this one on to my my entire family! Wonderful!
The book was great, it kept you on the edge of your seat. Unlike any I have ever read where you know the main characters will make it through the book or most of the way, you never know from minute to minute who will be killed off. I stayed surprised. The only disappointment if the abundance of explicit sexual details including same sex encounters. I have a good imagination and don't need every single detail spelled out. I am not a prude but felt it had too much. It took away from the story. The narrator was very good.
A Game of Thrones is a well-written story, with different characters' perspectives woven together to tell a tale of adventure, power, and honor. Great in the fantasy genre as well as in the literature genre.
I usually don't listen to books that I've not first read in written form, but A Game of Thrones is an exception. Roy Dotrice's excellent narration kept me engaged and interested. I definitely recommend this as both an audiobook and as a book to read.
educator and technologist
Great characters, great story, great read. I've read it twice and watched the HBO series. With the series I've started re-reading them all.
Several reviews were tepid about the reader Roy Dotrice, but I thought the performance was superb, and made the book for me. I had not read the book prior to listening, so had no pre-formed conclusions.
I also had a couple of long drives, so I was able to listen to large parts of the book at one "sitting".
All in all a great performance!
I am quite sure I would have enjoyed this if the narrator didn't deliver in such a monotone voice.