A lot of fantasy books are usually quite hard to read in the beginning. The authors feel like they need to explain every single detail in the beginning before the real story get startet. But here you dig right into the action and get intrigued at once.
That its not just one main character, that often gets boring. And you get told which persons view you are observing from. A lot of books jump back and forward until you loose track and have to start all over again.
The way he change his voice after character and remember the distinguished sound of each one.
his performance was excellent , his voice went with all the emotions of the characters of the story and a different voice for each one .... EXCELLENT !
The story about the family of the north. The rest felt overused in literature.
Utilize a unique viewpoint or story.
Not original at all, not worth it.
Father of three
I initially purchased this book three years ago when I first plunged into the the worlds of Ice and Fire. I loved the story, but had a hard time listening to it. There are so many different characters that it was hard to keep them straight. I would miss the name of the narrator at the start of the chapter and be lost as to what was happening. After book one, I gave up on listening to the story and switched to the print version.
After watching several seasons of the HBO series, I was intrigued to go back to it again. I suspected that there was much more to the story than what HBO showed. So I reloaded the book and began listening.
Wow. what a story. There is so much that I missed the first time around. Knowing the story from having read it once and then watching the series, it is easy to follow the plot and therefore to focus on the details. It is fun to see the connection between the different characters and to know how their different decisions will play out. I love the book much more the second time around. I am now in Book 2 and resigned to spending my summer working my way forward through the rest.
The one area where I struggle now is where the book characters (and the accents that the narrator give them) differs from the HBO series. Arya is not a cute little girl, but a 'horse-face girl." Daenerys is only 14. Rob is 15. Joeffry is 13. Ser Jorah Mormont should be a muscular man. I have to force myself to picture the characters as the author described them rather than as HBO portrays them.
If you've read the books once, I would encourage you to come back and listen to them again.
I was recommended Game of thrones by a friend I wasn't sure if I wanted to get in to such a series of books just because of the length of time I would have to put in to listening to the books so I started watching the game of thrones on HBO I was sucked in to the story almost immediately the story with all the charactors was very interesting the series twist and turns seem to be a little bit more creative then some of the books plot twists but those plot twists are what make this book most enjoyable
When John Snow the bastard finds Ghost and what a asshole Veserious is to Dani and of course what happens to Ned Stark
all the unique voices songs and sounds he is able to do I couldn't imagine a better narrator for this book the must be able to do over 100 different voices he is great so far I am on about 3/4's finished with A Clash of Kings Book 2 but I hope he narrates the whole series
I cant figure Tyrian Lanister out his whole family is evil but is he like them or is he different?
if you watch the show on television like I do its still a interesting book but I like to know whats coming up next so I want to finish the books before they show the episodes
I would consider it a close second.
The execution of the Hand and the events leading up to it and immediately after.
I listen on my way to and from work. I have a long commute and he makes it a lot shorter as I am never ready to stop listening when I am finally home. I like his voice and how he tries to differentiate between each character. He does a decent job with the female voices all things considered.
It's been done and done well already by HBO.
Highly recommend this version as a companion to the written version.
I am reading the book as well as listening to it. The match up of the book to the recording is great as I can go back and forth as needed. Roy Dotrice's voices make the book come alive. Compared to the TV program, it is not the word for word screenplay but the complexity of the book is literally more real.
The dire wolves discovery - since I had seen the discovery on the small screen, the book description was more evocative of the moment. I could feel the pups, hear their sounds and smell their acceptance. The screen seemed to gloss over the scene, so that I remembered Greyjoy more than the pups.
His ability to create the many voices of the book, bring it to life - differently than the actors do in the scenes. Wonderful characters, brought to life.
Winter is coming.
I found this was a great way to "read" a book I've wanted to read but haven't had the time to pick up the hard copy. I'm very glad I purchased my Audible membership to allow the opportunity to "read" more than just stuff I'd read at work.
This was my first book read by Mr. Dotrice. I noticed numerous people complain about having issues understanding some of the accents used. I disagree and thought it was well done with no problems understanding what was being said (although it was strange not hearing the voices that I'm used to hearing on the TV show).
The authors in depth descriptions of the visual aspects of the story from the surroundings, to the clothing and the battles were thoroughly engulfing.
There were several interesting plot lines that I was always anxious to catch up on as the author brought each one back;
The reader's ability to bring each character to life in his voice and intonation was astounding; it sounded like a troupe of actors not one person.
Some parts were sad;
I enjoy history, biographys, and nerdy/ dorky things.
The deception, the mystery, the magic all work in together to create a great story.
This was my second read through. I read all the books before watching the TV series. If your a fan of medieval stories/ D&D, etc, you will enjoy this book.
He gives every character a different voice, and personality.
Having the TV series give a face to each character has helped. I was worried listening to the book again might be a waste of time. I caught onto so many little teed-bits of information I had either forgotten, of glanced over on my first read.