Definitely a mature book for older readers
The book is great but I could follow
I only listened to a few minutes due to lack of interest
It just wasn't for me
I like that the author took on a huge amount of time to create this book. What I disliked is that the reader was hard to follow and I wasn't a fan of it at all. My friend goes on and on about this book and I used my credit on this thinking that I would have some in site into my friend's discussions. I learned that I am not a fan of the genre.
Yes, kind of. But I don't think it is the book's fault. I didn't know I wasn't a fan of the genre before I bought the book because I have never picked up a book of this genre before..
I would change the clarity in his voice. If he just read the book instead of using voices for the characters. It was really annoying.
Okay, so I don't like this book. I loved the first chapter and thought I would go on loving the rest. Yes, George Martin is an excellent writer. If only everyone didn't die or suffer grievous injury. I am only 1/3 through the first in the series. I don't think I am actually going to be able to finish this book. Violence and death can fit in a story but do they have to overwhelm it? Nobody stays around long enough for a multi volume story to go anywhere, except some of the bad guys it appears. And then I have an issue with the author's tendency to have prepubescent or very young teen girls be sexual objects, often involving rape or violent sex. There is something disturbing about that. Most of the women, at least in this volume, are little more than sexual objects.
There are so many things I wanted to know more about: the long winter, Winterfell, what was beyond the wall. But I am not willing to trudge through several volumes to find out.
Not for me. And I am not going to apologize.
I haven't read the print version. As time allows, I may go back and read it. Not sure though. There are so many fantastic books available. Time may never be allowed.
The story and the characters evolve and develop. There's not always a happy ending. Main characters can die. The story pulls you in emotionally.
I may have liked to, but considering the length, that will never happen.
The performance of the reader is excellent at times. The different voices for the characters are sometimes spot-on, but often miss the mark and is a distraction to following the story.
Good tale, but the performance gets a little tring after a while
I would not JUST listen to this audiobook. It is great as background story to dinner preparations or folding laundry or doing something with your hands that doesn't consume your mind. But I would not lie back on the couch and just listen to this audiobook as my sole activity. The narration bothered me after a while, the pacing, pronunciation ("PeTIRE" for Petyr, among others really got to me), and inability to stress key words during dialogue, the way normal people speak led to some frustrating moments of wishing I could have spoken to the narrator about how he was reading the story. The same frustration does not occur when Jim Dale narrates Harry Potter, or Martin Freeman narrates The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.
It is similar to many epic stories, like The Lord of the Rings, where battles, politics and character building all go hand-in-hand. These stories also have to juggle multiple characters and multiple viewpoints,which can be challenging as the reader/listener of a book.
The narrator made the female characters rather snivelling (a common problem with male narrators). He also chose some unique pronunciations for words in the book (e.g. PeTIRE for Petyr), and had some awkward pacing of dialogue, failing to stress words that should have been emphasized, and, resultingly, downplayed some important scenes.
It already has multiple follow-up books. They are needed and fantastic.
I will not purchase any other audiobooks narrated by Roy Dotrice. Judging by his approach to narration, I will likely be disappointed by his stylistic decisions. There are so many other better-skilled narrators.
After the HBO series everyone should know this. This is a great yarn! The characters are fully and completely developed. You care about these people. You understand their motivations. The sense of impending doom that hangs about the entire procedings lends a piquancy to their stories that is almost heartbreaking. You just feel that something... enormous, scary, inevitable... is about to happen and throw everything into chaos. The book is the first in a series, fine. It doesn't drop you on your head. The end feels right. A place to pause and reflect before continuing. Its a huge book, again, fine. It needs to be huge. There are a lot of moving pieces, many plots, much double dealing and wheels within wheels. It's daunting and embracing. The narration is first class. Roy Dotrice seems to be having the time of his life energizing this reading. Seriously, get this audio. It is superb. Just a couple of retraces, but no one is perfect.
I don't think I can sum this book up in just 3 words. I love the complicated storyline, the many characters and subplots, and the lessons and trial each character goes through and how they are all interconnected. This is the first of a series, so it is a good introduction and forshadowing to what may come in subsequent books. I will say I watched the HBO series and it was excellent. I would recommend watching. Usually, I'm disappointed with the book-made-into a movie, but the beautiful scenery, the actors chosen to play the characters and the visual beautity of the clothing etc really helped bring the novel to life. They didn't leave anything out!
I thought the narrator did a good job with the book.
I couldn't stop listening, but since it is about 48 hours long, it couldn't be done in one sitting. However, I carried my ipod/iphone around with me non-stop so I could listen at every opportunity. I had already watched the HBO program, so it wasn't like I didn't know what was going to happen next, but I still wanted to listen to it!
I think the book is great, and I think the reader is great.
The language is fun, and playful, and interesting; it is different enough to put me in a fantasy realm, but common enough to be clearly understood. The story is beyond epic.
The reading is great. It may take time to get used to, but that is to be expected. I think Dotrice does an admirable job, and I think he makes as much use of his vocal capabilities as could be hoped for.
I'm a cheap person, and I like to make sure I'm getting my money's worth. While I initially resented having to pay two credits (is that just because the books are so popular now, with the HBO show?), I think this is completely worth it... I've paid double credits for each book in the series and will happily do so until the series is finished.