Not better, just different; if you like audiobooks, it was reasonably well done.
The narrator sounded like an elderly man, and, as such, he made most of the characters sound like old men, even the young male and female characters. He also made minor errors regularly, like calling Prince Joffrey
Roy Dotrice was the only reason I listened beyond (incestuous sex scene) part 2 (of 4); he made the misery enjoyable for a time. I believe someone may have been urinating in Martins Cheerios each morning (rape scene) before he started writing.
AGoT is a miserable soap opera where story lines just get strung alone ad nauseam until the betrayal is revealed (another incest scene). Each session of listening leaves me in a terrible mood. The entire book is the political fantasy equivalent of tantric sex.
(sex spoiler alert) the rape scene where the barbarians fight over who gets to rape a girl first and the victor chooses another woman to rape instead of the one they were fighting over.
GRR Martin doesn't even care about the characters, why should I care?
buyers remorse has never been more (rape scene) depressing
Story is gripping!
Eddard Stark is such a great character. He is the father and husband we all want and a true man of honor.
He uses his voice like an instrument, changing it to match each character's personality and mood.
Game of Thrones is to books what LOST is to television series. George RR Martin's day job is TV writer. He begins by writing three books that really suck you in. You will become very attached to all of the many characters. After that, be warned: the story does not resolve. You will get a dream sequence when you want plot resolution. You will get three new characters and their back story when what you want desperately to know what happens to the character you just read a thousand pages about. Just because half of one of the first books is spent on a character central to the plot does not mean you will ever find out what happens to that character. On the other hand, characters you don't care about at all because they have no bearing on the past or future plot will get 5 chapters. Some characters just disappear.
My husband and I watched six seasons of LOST. It nearly gave me high blood pressure that the events of the first three seasons had nothing to do with the second three. I wanted to pull my hair out when the plot lines that drew me in were never revisited. I wanted to scream when a new character was introduced instead of seeing an existing characters story to it's end. My husband did not seem to care as much and was happy with the
John Snow, because of his struggle for identity.
This is the Lord of
I wish there were 34 hours in a day so that I could have finished this in a day.
Sure, there would be more details come out when listening a second time. The story is quite complex and I plan to listen to the next book and then watch the TV series and probably listen again after that.
The ending. I don't want to give it away, but the whole scene with Daenerys and the fire and dragons was riveting.
He was an excellent narrator and his reading did not distract from the details of the book. Sometimes the reader has a voice or something that distracts me. This was not the case with Mr. Dotrice. I will listen to more books by him.
~ Lizardbeth ~
For the most part, the reader's performance was excellent. However, there were some voices he did that were almost unbearable to listen to, specifically those that sounded, for lack of a better word, "saliva-heavy." It was like he was kicking up spit in the corners of his mouth purposefully for these voices; the "Eunuch" being the one that occurred most often. I forced myself to listen to these voices because what they had to say was often very relevant, and (b) the rest of the story was still very, VERY good, but it definitely affected my overall enjoyment of the book as I dreaded those characters having dialogue.
The story was fantastic however, and I was absolutely riveted from start to finish. In spite of the performance, I'll definitely be purchasing the rest of the series in audiobook form (I'm a cartoonist & artist professionally, and having long audiobooks to listen to while I work is far more enjoyable for me, besides not having to squeeze in reading time elsewhere.) The reader doesn't put me off that badly; it's only small minority of characters' voices I find off-putting, and while that's enough to lower my overall rating of the audiobook it's not enough to prevent me from buying future books. It is a consideration however for those of you who are either more bothered by poor reader performances, or have the free time to read the book instead.
No. Great story, characters, but an inordinate amount of pointless detail. A conservative estimate of 60% is useless description of people. histories, events, etc.which adds nothing to the story. I am five books into this story and the author is nowhere near pulling all the far-flung threads together. At this pace it could easily take another five books to complete this story. I'm sorry to say I won't be there when it happens.
Maybe, if I thought it was interesting. But if after one book I saw the same style as above I would drop it.
Have him listen to his narration so that after his return in book five his pronunciation of some names and places was the same.
Spend your credits on other books.
Travel a lot for work and spend a good deal of time in the car.
Every book in this series is 1000 times better then the print version, with the exception of A Feast For Crows( John Lee sucks)
Everything about this story great! Just get it. Even if you have already seen season 1 of GOT on HBO you should still listen to this.
Roy Dotrice is a Wizard. He uses his magic story telling abilities to make this story come alive. If you dont believe me you will see when you listen to A Feast For Crows and want to claw your ears off when John lee croaks out the words like he is reading some edgar allan poe verse on a highschool stage. But dont claw your ears off...roy will be back for book 5.
this is my favorite book series outside of Dragon Riders of Pern.(Anne McCaffrey..not her son...he is garbage.)
I bought into George R R Martin's series because so many of my friends played the card game. I figured I'd take a look into the book, not expecting too much out of it.
I must say, I'm quite hooked now. I felt the story started out slow, and can be difficult to follow at first, with the variety of characters and viewpoints. It helps to have a chart or something visual to connect all the relationships.
But, the beginning aside, the story was fabulous. I immediately purchased the second book and am looking forward to listening to it.