I will probably purchase the rest of the series, but I wish I could get them with a different narrator, and more important: a different style of narration. I use audiobooks rather than traditional reading because I'm physically too busy to read. Audiobooks let me do exercise, housework, crafts and even some of the more braindead tasks at work while reading. But it's the story I want, the words, the text. I don't need or like all the acting from the narrator, all the different voices assigned to the different characters. A man in his fifties will never sound like a ten year old girl, so why pretend to? Better a blank canvas that I can fill with my own imagination - as similar to traditional reading as possible.
Also, Dotrice's voice is to raspy for my liking, plus he has a tendency to make really annoying, sputtering, gargly voices for particularly the elderly characters. I don't care if an ageing Black Knight in real life probably would sound really unpleasant - I still don't like having my ears tortured unnecessarily.
The variants of characters and environments. It was all greatly detailed and makes you feel like your actually there in the story.
The code. The way that those who lived in an era such as this lived by, we all need to have a code of honor such as this.
various voices and depth to the expressions of the characters
laugh at parts, but so made me hate the Lanisters!
Listen on dog walks, commutes and around the house. Welcome virtually any genre but southern fiction holds a special place in my heart.
I generally do not read fantasy but I was drawn to the HBO series and watched it from start to finish. As Season 2 of the series approaches, I have a strong desire to read the second book prior to watching the season. I debated whether to read the first book, A Game of Thrones, before venturing into the second book. Being a purist at heart, I had to and I'm happy I did. My mind's eye, however, was forever set by the characters cast for the series and there was nothing I could do about it. The Cersei, Joffrey, Catelyn, Daenerys, Sansa, and Arya I imagined as I read the book where inexplicably linked to the series. I was also amazed at how well the series captured the entire story laid out in A Game of Thrones. If this is the Grey's Anatomy of fantasy series, as one other reviewer has referred to it, then please give me more McDreamy!
I have never liked anything in the fantasy genre before. I gave this a try because I really got into the HBO television series. Within the first two chapters, I knew I would be reading the entire series. I have become invested in each character as he/she develops, and speak to my husband about my hopes and worries for each, as though they are real people. The story keeps me on my toes. I cannot seem to leave this story alone for more than a few hours, and find myself looking forward to my public transportation rides to listen again. Roy Dotrice changes his reading style for each character to perfectly capture his/her attitude and personality. He is consistent and recognizable with these changes too. I could come into an unknown part of the book, and be able to tell which character was speaking just by listening to his inflection. Throw out all your previous biases toward fantasy and listen to this!
Roy Dotrice is an amazing narrator, he really makes this story come to life. It's a very high quality performance of an incredibly captivating story! I couldn't wait to get the next book, or the one after, or the one after that... I just can't put them down!
I'm actually reviewing the series, not just the first book. I've read all five in the series that are currently out. Books 1-3 are absolutely amazing. In fact, they get better as they go on with book three being the best in the series. They are the best epic fantasy I've ever read. Although I was glad to continue my reading experience with books 4 and 5, the series starts to show some cracks at this point. Essentially, the author continues to introduce more and more characters and unnecessarily convolutes the storyline and I simply got irritated and worn down by all the details. The author strays away from the core group of characters introduced in the first three books and I think this hurts the series. The 4th anf 5th books feel bloated and in need of a good edit. Don't get me wrong, they are still better than almost any other epic fantasy, they just aren't as good as the first three. Even with this criticism, I stongly recommend you read the series. the books are just phenomenal.
The language is incredibly vulgar. I don't mind cuss words here and there, but this book is saturated with them. There is also some rather explicit sex in the story as well. It is all incredibly distracting and ruins the enjoyment of the story. I had to quit after only an hour.
Yes. His reading of the text is great.
Absolutely, and I have :)
The political intrigue is completely engrossing, and the characters are phenomenal and presented very well.
His acting certainly fit the story but at times it seemed to detract from the flow. Overall very well done.
I have recommended this story to others.
First off, I've been a member for a couple of years and this is my first review. I felt I had to write something as this book irked me so.
I don't believe I would waste my time to try and get through another book by Mr. Martin and Mr. Dotrice. It was only until the last part of the four parts in Book one of this audio book series that I finally was able to understand somewhat the plot.
Delete about 200 or so miscellaneous characters. I found it impossible to follow the storyline with all these various names that really had little if anything to add to the plot. I felt sorry for the reader as he was trying to make up voices for the many characters and a few of his female voices were definitely sounding masculine.
It was either Dotrice's or whoever edited the Audible.com or most likely both who should have proofed & corrected the errors that made the audio book, at least for me, impossible to understand at times. Dotrice at numerous times throughout the reading would stop reading, have a long pause, and then began reading the same material that was just read previously. Very distractingly!
This book made me feel a certain amount of frustration and anger. This was shoddy work and never should have been released by Audible.com. It tends to make me wonder if the writer reviews his own work after the reader completes the book or if he even bothers to actually listen to his books at all after the reader finishes recording. Does not show me much pride in the author's own work. It was not very professional!
Proof your work before releasing it to the public.I found it hard to understand all the wonderful reviews this audio book received. As I said in my headline,