I got aware of this captivating series by the TV show which is brilliant. To read the book afterwards does not diminish the thrill, since the characters get so much more details and the history gets more depth because, well, they just couldn't put everything into one season. I recommend listening to the book to everyone who loved the show.
It took me some time to get used to Roy Dotrice and his reading and it still annoys me a bit when he pauses dramatically before - nothing special at all. Overall, he's doing a good job of bringing the characters to live, even the female ones.
Annoying is the production of this audiobook because the repitition of the last sentence on the next CD just doesn't make sense in a continuous audio stream. So if you wonder, why there are so many "misreadings", it's because they just put together the CDs without further editing...
former nuclear scientist
I got this book because I was blown away by the HBO series. My husband had the 2-inch-thick paperback, but we lost it in the move. I started it years ago, but made it to page 4 before I thought, "meh." The audiobook follows the book: you can tell by its 33-hour length that the novel is wordy. I'm a bit surprised at the level of cliches I have heard: cold "cutting like a knife," the queen "smiling coldly," etc. But I'm also surprised at how exceedingly well HBO got *almost every event* - as well as most of the important dialog, verbatim - into its miniseries. Bravo!
Now, the fact that I've seen this pitch-perfect adaptation means that I'm probably biased against any reader. Dotrice sounds very distinguished, like a prep school English teacher from 1954. Unfortunately, he really only has four voices: narration voice, a lusty bellow like the Baratheon actor in the miniseries, a high nasal, simultaneously condescending and sniveling lordling voice like a pompous Monty Python character, and some crafty mid-Atlantic voice like Bottomtooth in Family Guy. Oh, and the sailor who sounds like a pirate - really. Many of these voices seem mismatched to the characters, and he is a bit inconsistent throughout. Ned evolves from grizzled and gravely to a more normal and elegant sound when he has to interact with Baratheon and the reader needs to distinguish them. Khal Drogo sounds like a half-wit when the reader tries to make it sound like he doesn't speak the language well, drawling out "No?" like Scooby Doo.
So the story is great, the performance is not that great (though definitely not awful, just not up to the story, and sort of campy), and the book's narration is a bit wordy and hard to keep track of, which is why I give it four stars overall instead of five. If I hadn't been entranced by the HBO series, I mightn't be able to stick with this or follow it without multiple rewinds.
Huge & complex universe
The moral dilemma that its presented to Ned at the end when things happen to Robert.
No, but he is good giving life to each of the many characters in this huge universe
If you are going to play the game of thrones you either win or you die
It is an awkward feeling. I bought the audiobook because I was going to start to watch the HBO series and usually I try to read a book before watching the movie/series. Normally I end saying "The book was MUCH better, by a mile" but this time it was not like this. I really feel that the series is a masterpiece based on a good saga. There were some parts in the audiobook where I found myself expecting more, it was sometimes a little tedious. This never happened to me while watching the series.
The book is good, but do yourself a favor: Watch the series first. The drama is much more interesting followed on TV. If you read the book first you will not be so exited when watching the series, and that is a pity because they are THAT amazing.Then after you are finished with the TV series you can read the book so you fill into the history.
Ok, I am really trying to give this a good listen but I am having a very hard time with the narration. I may have to actually read this one instead of listening to it.
I have friends who recommended it to me. I really can't rate the story right now as I am only about 2 hours into it.
I don't really know.
My issue is with the narrator. I just have to go ahead and say something even though I have not finished the book. He shortens the words. Seven is pronounced "seb'm" and the first time he said the word gown, it sounded like "gun" and he combined the words "for you" into "foyu". I know this may be nit-picking but I listen to books on my commute to and from work. I don't mind a good book that makes you think but I don't like having to try to decipher the words while I drive. The names are hard to understand because I have not seen them in print. And even though I do appreciate some of his character voices, he continues the character voice during some transitions. The first time I heard this, I thought the character was speaking about himself in third person. He speaks the character voice and then things like "he said" or "so and so mounted his horse" is still in the character voice. I may have to read the book rather than listen, then come back later and listen after I've seen the words in print.
I have read the print version and listened to the audio version. I would say that they are equivalent. When Roy was narrating this one it was pretty clear that he hadn't quite gotten into the characters yet. So his narration on this one was just average. But he does improve as the series progresses.
He didn't really add much to the story, but he didn't take anything away either. In later books, he does much more value add narration.
I will not spoil it for anyone, but the last (or maybe it was the second to last) scene was my favorite. You will know it when you get to it. Trust me.
Valar Morghulis! Because that line sums up the whole series.
Finally gave up on trying to keep track of all the characters, all the locations, all the kingdoms. Might work as a movie where you can see them and associate names and faces but .....
best series ever
The Lord of the Rings - both are long epic tales that introduce characters and places galore
Amazing accents and voices for so many different characters. He switches back and forth seamlessly. He makes the books come to life.
I was in awe at the various ways that Roy Dotrice was able to produce so many different characters
Can't wait for the rest of the books...especially with Roy Dotrice as the narrator!
The intricate plots and epic scale are wonderful - the amount of effort poured into creating the world of Westeros really shows.
Eddard Stark - love the character who tries to do the right thing every time even when it seems everything is pointing to the easy way out.
He does a very good job giving each character their own voice, and changing the pace of the reading to match what's happening in the book.
I want to pick up a sword and skewer some Lannisters, if that counts
If you are looking for a happy-ending type book, this is not the one you want. This book is about power struggles and is not for the hero saves the day type.
I had a high school english teacher who read the Oedipus trilogy to our class with such enthusiasm and intrigue that it made a room full of 16 year olds sit up and pay attention to ancient literature for the first time. That's the gift that Roy Dotrice's performance lends to A Game of Thrones. Fantastic performance enhances and betters the story with spectacular character voices. The story itself is good too. Multiple plot lines could have been confusing being told in audio, but Dotrice does a good job shifting his voice a certain way to let you know the scene has changed. A must-read if you enjoy fantasy/dark ages fantasy.