I read the reviews about the reader not being good and the names not being pronounced well. But I disagree with that assessment of this reading. I think this book is excellently read. The voices are well done and interesting. It did take me a few chapters to understand the shift from one character to another. Once I understood that, it was very enjoyable, I actually waited for a shift.
The storyline in this book is very realistic, so realistic in fact, that I found it painful in many places. Martin didn't write a "good guys always end up on top" book. There were times that I needed to stop the book and catch my breath - since I didn't want the things that happened to happen. But it is as it would have happened in real mediaval life. I also enjoyed the very complex political undertow that was happening.
It took awhile to get into this book but if you like the fantasy genre
once you have all the characters straight this will be hard to shut off. I found myself rooting for the heros and wanting to see the demise of the antagonist. I recommend this book and will be getting the next book series.
I am looking forward to next in the series. I hope that having the first book in the series will lead to the other two in the line being made available as well. Great reader!
Unless you are British, Dotrice ruins this book. I could not get more than two hours into the book before I had to turn it off. It's like being lectured at by the most stuffy professor you have ever met. His manner of narating, long pauses followed by rapid fire speak, with deep stuffy accent, is too much to take. Too bad, I really wanted to listen to this series.
For anyone who enjoys authors like Robert Jordan, Tolkien, or L.E. Modesitt Jr., this book is meat and mead. The dark realism of Martin's setting is detailed, but not boring. The characters are very well developed and very unique. A bright point in this story is Martin's ability to make the reader feel for the characters. My only complaint is that Martin seems to rush through the first half of the book naming places and people and gives very little substance regarding where they are or who they are. Also, I too had trouble with Roy Dotrice's narration at first, but once I was used to it it only added to the mood of the story. I give this book five stars, and will be adding a hardcover copy to my ever-growing library of books I love.
I read this book and then went on to read the next two in the series. I thought they were so good that I went back and read them again. This is the best fantasy that I have ever read and I will now be buying the audio versions.
Perhaps it's the reader; perhaps it's the author's pace--either way, I found this book tiresome. I kept waiting for it to get better, but it never happened. The many plots were predictable. I wish I could say there was a character within the book that I admired, but I couldn't find one. I can not recommend this book.
I love George RR Martin's books, I've read them all and thought they were amazing. The reader of this book is awful. Most of his characeters sound like deranged pirates. Samwell? Yeah, he sounds like a pirate. Wrong, so wrong! I love these books and could not bring myself to finsh listening to the horrible narrator. Do yourself a favor, and actually read the book, don't listen.
I wouldn't recommend the book because I couldn't listen to the narrator. I suffered through about two hours hoping the story line would distract me from the dreadful reading but it didn't. I will be asking for my credit back.
Couldn't tell you because, for me, it was unlistenable due to the boring drone of the reader.
In every way. For me, he was so bad that I couldn't get past about two hours. I listen while driving 40 miles to and from work but with this book I found I simply stopped listening although it was playing. He bored the pants off me.
This is an epic story. I have read this book and seen the HBO series. The story itself is very emotionally difficult and not for everyone, but very engaging. The character development is exquisite. GRRM does not follow typical conventions, such as keeping main characters safe, etc. Expect to be devastated many times.
This narrator is horrible. Having not only read the books, but also seen the HBO series, I'm very familiar with the tale. I found the same thing many others have complained about with the reader - his accent is difficult sometimes to understand because he runs his words together. Additionally, he pronounces the characters' names differently at different times. He puts the same gravelly voice on a variety of different characters - men, women - when voice acting. I don't find them at all congruent with the characters (and I know the characters). I just wanted to refresh myself of the books since it has been a long while since I read them and the TV series is on, so I thought I would just listen to them since I am in the car a lot. But I doubt I will be able to stand it. Also, it was pretty expensive and I am regretting buying the book now.
Not with this reader.
PLEASE, George R. R. Martin - read these yourself so we can hear it read appropriately!