Actually, I'm Morris's wife, Dawn, an avid reader.
I have been meanng to read this book for some time, having seen it on so many "recommended" lists. I am a writing teacher and am especially sensitive to the use of language. I was immediately captivated by Hurston's exquisite descriptions and observations about human nature and race relations. I've since bought the book so I can underline the passages I especially love.
I've listened to many audio books but have never heard a better reader than Ruby Dee. What a wonder she is, making this book come alive with her many varied and realistic voices.
The writing was good and kept me listening even while I hated to listen to Ruby Dee.
I didn't have one in particular...Janie would be too obvious, I think.
NO! She made every character sound angry, old, and drunk. It was hard to listen to because she was the narrator.
Perhaps, if that was possible.
If it wouldn't have been a such a waste of money, I would have stopped listening because of the narrator. I cannot say that enough. I thought I was just being harsh but I let my husband and kids listen and they all agreed that, though I am sure she was a lovely woman and talented actress, she was not a good narrator.
I had a hard time reading the printed text because I generally have a hard time reading anything written in dialect. I am even annoyed when I get misspelled text messages from relatives written in dialect because I have to reconstruct what they are supposed to say. After reading the text, I thought an audiobook version would be lovely but I have to disagree with most reviewers. This is a beautiful love story and although the main character is older in the novel she strikes me as in her 40s during the telling of the story. Hearing Ruby Dee's narration is sort of like having your grandmother tell you about her love story. Although she did a great job, it took me out of the story a bit and I would have enjoyed a younger voice.
Narrator Ruby Dee made this book come to life in a variety of voices, emotions, and moods. This book is poetry with a complex main character. It's a definite "must read" for book clubs.
Although I had read the book in print, the narration of this audiobook moved me to tears multiple times. I was stunned at how much of the story and emotion I had missed in the print book. Ruby Dee did a phenominal job as the narrator. I can't imagine this book read by anyone else.
Besides incessant listening to audiobooks, I also read on my Kindle at night, birdwatch, garden (roses, daylilies), and do genealogy.
I was a little worried when I first started listening that I would not like the book or the narration. I was so wrong as I soon learned. This is an amazing story with an even more incredible narration by Ruby Dee. It was a very enjoyable and memorable listen and I highly recommend it.
I think listening to this book really added to the atmosphere of the writing. The reader was SOOO good! I think it would be harder to understand if I had just tried to read it myself. It is written in black southern dialect. -- I can't believe this book was written in 1934. It was definitely way before it's time. I liked the characters and I liked the message of being who you want to be, not just what everyone else wants you to be. --There were funny parts, sad parts, and somewhat intense parts. This book is definitely a five star read!
If you fail to give this one a try you are only cheating yourself out a wonderful experience! A beautifully written story that is fabulously narrated! Definitely will be on my list of "all time favorites".
Retired CFO, Army wife, Mom of five, Grandma of six, two sons who served in combat, love to read books that reflect my values and faith, love mysteries, historical, military stories, and books that don't waste my time . . . if it doesn't have an ending that was worth the wait, I'm not a happy camper.
1920s and 1930s Florida, this is the life of Janie Crawford . . . from the first stirrings of love as sixteen year old when Janie watched bees pollinating the pear tree in her Nanny's yard, and equated this to what marriage should be like, to her two failed marriages, and then to Tea Cake, her one true love . . . a beautifully and honestly written story of a young black woman, raised by her grandmother, who was once a slave . . . the southern accents and pronunciations are perfect . . . listening is much preferred over actually reading . . . this is not a book just for African Americans . . . its a tale for all of us . . . anyone who has a spirit and a dream deep within their heart . . .