donald t wardlow
This book, and "the Stand," by Stephen King, go back and forth in my mind as far as being the best book ever. Mr. Horsley brings this book to life as only a Texan can do, even better than the skilled narrator who did the audio for the Library of Congress. He was good--Horsley is exceptional. He captures the brashness of Gus, the savagery of Blue Duck, the timid nature of July Johnson, and so much more. With such an epic to work with, many potential narrators would be overwhelmed. This reading lends an added dimension to an amazing book--more realistic than anything John Ford ever put on the screen. In this real Wild West, the good guys certainly don't always win, and even the good guys show the character flaws that make them seem more real than any hero John Wayne ever portrayed. McMurtry only wrote two other books worth bothering with--Streets of Laredo, the sequel to this book, and "Last Picture Show." Other than that, don't even bother. Forget the two prequels, they're worthless. This is easily my favorite western, and as i stated at the outset, one of my two favorite books of all.
Not at ALL the type of book I normally pick up, but based on the reviews and ratings I decided to give it a try. They were spot on.
It snuck up on me, but by the halfway point I found myself caring about Augustus McCrae in a way I never would have expected based on the first couple hours.
I REALLY realized how good it was when I was listening while driving and noticed my entire body was tensed up during a fight scene because I was so wrapped up in the events. Wow. That's some good writing!
It made me want to experience a cattle drive! :)
If you enjoy a charater driven story that just happens to happen in the old west, this is your best bet. The author constructs his people with care and empathy. One is truly sad when misfortunes occur and can revel in the humor and humanity of those who overcome their adversities.
The sexual content is relevent without being puriant or gratuitous. It just all rings true.
It took me a little while to get used to the narrator's voice and chararcterizations. I thought that at the very beginning he moved a little too fast. But once he did slow down the pace was perfect.
Complaints about Gus' voice are understandable. But because Gus is so outrageous, his voice needs to be outrageous as well. After a while, it just made me smile when he spoke.
This book is wonderful and tragic all at the same time. If you have ancestors who lived in some of the places that this story covers at the time this this story takes place, it may give you a new respect for the lives they may have led and the times that they lived in. I look forward to listening other books by L.M.
McMurtry is a genius with characters, and Horsley's reading of Gus MacRae, Woodrow Call, and Clara Allen are outstanding. This epic novel is a gritty, realistic portrait of the west as it teetered on the cusp of being settled (or as Gus would have said, "Ruint"). Lonesome Dove's west is populated by adventurers, pirates, sociopaths, and extraordinarily strong women. The novel is thoroughly entertaining and lends itself well to being read.
This book is nothing short of spectacular. Not only is it a fantastic book, it is by far and away the best job of reading of any book I've listened to, and I have listened to plenty. This is not a Western in any traditional sense, but an unabashed story of life, by an author with an incredible sense for the rhythms of life, and a reader of great sensitivity who brings every character into his own. I guaranty you will not regret getting this book.
I love literary fiction and I occasionally delve into non-fiction. I love books that are suspenseful and am really into well-told stories.
I read Lonesome Dove 23 years ago and have seen the miniseries several times. I know that Gus has a loud voice, but the actor doesn't need to scream, sending my sleeping cats scattering and me racing for the volume control every time he talks.... and Gus is a main character. (and one of the best leading men ever written in literature)
This book is a masterpiece~~and I don't need to finish it to know that. But I doubt I'll finish this version. 35 hours of this isn't too much fun.
PLEASE RE-RECORD THIS!!!!! It deserves it! I don't think there is anything wrong with the performance by Lee Horsley...because the voices are all OK except for Gus'. I'm going to complain to Audible...and I was warned in reading some of the other reviews that there were sound quality issues... but it's worse than anyone said.
My advice is to not buy this until they come up with a new recording of it. I'm mad that I wasted a credit on a book I was REALLY looking forward to re-reading.
M A Stoever
I've been downloading two Audible titles a month for almost two years, and so far Lonesome Dove is the most memorable: an exciting and moving story populated with brilliantly created characters, brought to life by a fine narration.
I have always been a fan of the Lonesome Dove mini-series and remember watching that with my dad. Even to this day if it is “lazy day” we will pop that in and watch it. For just as long, I have been hearing about how amazing the book is. I tried to read the prequels a few years back and was not impressed. However I have heard many folks praise this book and now I can see why! I enjoy gritty fiction (lately GRR Martin or Joe Abercrombie), and this is very similar in writing style and character types, in that you feel conflicted about the protagonist. At one point you may like a character, only to dislike them 10 minutes later for something they say or do. Nothing is black or white, but many shades of gray in between with these characters. I find the same emotions GRR Martin or Abercrombie evoked while listening to those, being felt in this book. It is not necessarily the setting, be it fantasy or western, that makes a book this amazing, it is the characters. Also it is one helluva way to end the book the way McMurty did in the last few sentences, but it makes you think the whole thing over. Would definitely be a great book for a book club discussion!
My only criticism of this audio book is the narrator. At times he did an amazing job, but his reading of Gus was very distracting. It felt as though Gus was ALWAYS yelling. It was so distracting at first I found myself getting irritated. However over time I got used to it and am quite glad I did not give up!
I am not a fan of Western fiction, but decided to purchase this one due to its fame and awards, and because I found out it had been one of my grandfather's favorite books. The best aspect of the story is the characters, who come alive with a beauty of economy rarely seen. The setting also comes alive, and I enjoyed getting a good feel for what it was like to live in Texas during this time period. Being transported to a time and place is the greatest pleasure of historical fiction.
My disappointment comes from the terrible audio quality and poor narration. The volume varies widely, so that one must adjust the volume continually. Sometimes the volume drops extremely low. Sometimes it is extremely loud: one of the characters is described as having a loud voice, and that is taken literally in the narration, so that this character's dialogue is about three times louder than the others. No only is this annoying, it makes it impossible to listen to the book with earphones without risking hearing damage, let alone being startled out of your skin over and over.
The recording and editing are also of poor quality. The book sounds as if it were recorded at different times in different studios with different equipment. Sometimes there are delays between sentences, other times parts of sentences are repeated. At times the audio is clear, at other times it sounds like it was recorded with an old portable cassette tape player from the 70s.
I like the narrator's voice, as it seems very appropriate for the material, and he does a decent job varying the character's voices. But this recording is in serious need of a good director and editor.