Just loved it. I laughed, I cried, I couldn't wait to get back to it.
I can't imagine the movie being able to portray the complex and amazing 9 year old Oskar as written by Foer. And the narrators were just fabulous. Very entertaining. I'll be listening to it again.
I rent audio books to break up my long commute. This book was entertaining and captured my interest from beginning to end. An inappropriate child and odd family dynamic keep you wanting to know what happens next. The unfiltered thoughts of an unemotional, intellegent child give a dark but true view of the world.
It blatantly tries to emotionally move you in the cheapest possible way.
The best thing he could have done is not write it.
Cheap emotional titillation.
This is a remarkable book! Others will tell of the story line, but I will tell of my longing for time immersed in the story listening and wanting for more time to remain there. There is such power in this story, a way into the heart of love, lost, and how hard it is to be a parent. I just couldnt believe how much more powerful it was than the movie.
I really liked the conversations between Oscar and Thomas. It's very realistic and it reminds me of when I asked my parents questions when I was little. The whole dialogue is very well performed and written.
I loved the detail and performance of the part when Oscar and his mother are visiting a shrink and he's listening through the door.
Yes. This one is great--the author does a wonderful job shifting character's voices. I enjoyed all the narrators in this book.
The part about Dresden made me sad, but it was a great description/narrative. That in contrast with the description of 9/11 was hauntingly similar. Very well written.
In the second part, Chapter 3 just a few seconds before !;28:43, the grandmother is in the middle of her narrative and then Oscar's voice pops in--it didn't completely make sense to the story..I think it might be a syncing error...?
Don't know how to rate it.
First one for me
Thomas the grand father.
Little Thomas grand mother. She just seem to have more of a story to tell.
After many recommendations, I had been wanting to read this book for years. The story was slow, plodding and maybe interesting to a New Yorker or big city person. Plot was not believable and the main character, Oscar, not particularly admirable. First listen I came very close to not finishing.
I can only say great things! An amazing story told in a unique way by vivid characters. The readers were outstanding. There's a lot of pain in this book and some moments of joy. I like fiction that gives me an emotional ride, and this sure did!
love to read
not applicable as I have not yet read the print version.
When Oscar's Gramma is telling her tale of how she could see, and was hitting the space bar over and over and over. Sad, and telling.
I wouldn't. I love the title.
I recommend this book for everyone. My Sixteen year old listened with me and enjoyed it very much.