I AM STILL ONLY IN THE FIRST PART. I LEFT IT 2X NOW TO LISTEN TO OTHER BOOKS WHICH I FINISHED IN NO TIME.THEY WERE JUST A LOT MORE INTERESTING. WHEN I RETURN ITS OK BUT MY MIND WANDERS. I HOPE IT GETS BETTER AS I PURCHASED BASED ON OTHER REVIEWS.
I don't understand giving 5 stars to this book. The Lord of the Rings is five stars. Song of Ice and Fire maybe would get five stars. This book does not compare to either of those. I liked the story ok, but I found a lot of times I was either bored or annoyed.
I don't like that his characters all seem to have modern, american sensibilities, but that it's supposed to be another world, and pre-industrialized at that. I don't like that the university, which is such a big part of this story, is much like a modern university--tuition, finals, dorms, mess hall, etc. It just seems very anachronistic and contrived.
And how many different types of money are there? I can hardly keep track of them all or how much they're worth. Jots, chits, drams, talents, and on and on. At one point it seems like a talent is this huge sum of money, but then Kvothe pays a fee to enter a library of a talent and a half like it's nothing.
[TINY SPOILER ALERT]
Another thing that bothers me a lot is that Kvothe is supposed to be this great performer, brought up as a trouper, performing around the world with his entire family, but yet, when he is poor and needs money, he never thinks once to try to make it by performing. Not only that, but at one point he says that the students at the university all pay to go see people perform
I will never again buy a book without first listening to a sample. It's my fault. I have never done that before and now I've paid for it. I bought this book based on the wild reviews and comments here. Within the first 5 minutes of listening I knew I was going to have a very hard time with this book. Maybe it's just me book the reader sounds like a 22 year old frat boy who tries WAY to hard to bring diversity to his characters. If he tries to drop his voice to low, which he does often, it start to sounds gravelly and tone less. I couldn't take it any more after 5 chapters, which is unfortunate because the story line indeed seems to be promising and the author writes very well. So my suggestion.....Read the book, or at least listen to a sample of the reader to see whether you can at least stomach him.
I will read every thing Patrick writes. He came out of the chute bucking on the back of a
horse that has never been rode...and he's a champion in his first rodeo... Go Patrick and don't look back".......Paul T.
A different narrator.
Insisted on a different narrator!
I was looking forward to listening to this acclaimed book, but the narrator's inflections, tone, and interpretation were annoyingly sing-song and continually inappropriate to the story. I couldn't listen beyond an hour. Can I get a credit refund??
Wish I knew enough about the story to answer this.
I suppose you could say I enjoyed this book despite the poor writing. First of all, I don't like a story about telling a story about another person telling a story. Plus some of the lore was just... weak. Pretty much the Christmas story with a few details tweaked. You can totally tell the framing narrative was added after the fact. A good writer wouldn't have needed to add that in; it sorta destroys the "here and now" feeling of being caught up in the moment. AND he gives away some twists and turns of the plot with his interruptions - pet peeve of mine. He's very heavy-handed with it in the beginning, but once he lightens up and stops interrupting himself, the story actually gets enjoyable.
Others are right, the world is not very immersive. At times he goes into some detail indoors but generally I find myself wandering through a vague and misty world with no concept of space. Others' imaginations may be active enough to overcome this, but I need some more detail and imagery.
The constant emphasis of how smart and special Kvothe is just rubs me the wrong way. Above average I'm fine with, but better than anyone who's ever been? Constantly exceeding everyone's expectations? Come on. Perhaps this book was written for boys/teens/young adults who like to daydream about how awesome they would be if they could be the best at everything. Now I know why I'm the only girl who has read this in my friend's circle.
Though like I said, I liked it. I'm not above eeking out whatever enjoyment I can. Despite bad writing and a poor character choices, Rothfuss hits strides on occasion that I was able to enjoy and get involved in.
I don't have much of an opinion on the reader. I prefer a deeper voice for storytelling, but this guy does alright. He's very good at putting emotion in his voice & you often don't need the little exposition afterward to communicate the tone the character is using. He's got a better range for voices than Roy Dotrice, but that still doesn't put him in the same league.
I don't usually review books. I figure I either like them or I don't, and it's usually a manner of taste and style. This book, however, was so boring that I couldn't listen to more than a few hours of it. Apparently written for teenagers, there are no insights here, no world building, no secrets, no innovation, and really, no fantasy either. Not sure how he did it, but Rothfuss managed to turn what might have been an interesting story into some sort of coming of age sigh-maker. Rothfuss surely isn't an explorer of souls as is Guy Kay, and he surely isn't the master storyteller as is Jordan, isn't the magic technocrat as is Sanderson, nor is he the world builder as is Martin. Nor, to his high discredit, is he the coming of age storyteller of a Rowling. Fact is, his prose is trite and simplistic, his characters unidimensional, his story unimaginative, and his plot twists inane.
The reader certainly doesn't help much either.
I see a lot of folks liked this book, but I certainly did not. I'd advise the hard core fantasy fans to spend their credit elsewhere.
The headline says it all. All of the good qualities of the Harry Potter series (interesting and likeable main character), meshed perfectly with some of the more adult themes present in A Song of Ice and Fire.
You will not be disappointed.
I thought this book was wonderful! I know I shouldnt be making comparisons but I'm going to anyway. I am a big fan of Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time series and have been waiting for another as good. As far as I can tell from this book, Patrick Rothfuss will soon be a contender, at least in my library. If you like Robert Jordan and Brandon Sanderson you wont be disappointed with this one.
I was disappointed by the constant pain, misery and suffering of the protagonist. It hurt to listen so I quit.