I had high hopes for this, especially after the beginning sections. Then, the whole thing fell apart for me. It was tiresome and a chore to listen to. But I finished it. So, it's done. Now I'm going to read what I want.
This is one of the very best contemporary American novels I've read/listened to. It's offers some wonderfully intense, sustained interrogations of why modern lives aren't as satisfying subjectively as they should be, even when objective circumstances are favorable. The literary form used is interesting. The narrator is very good. Occasionally, there are slight lapses in sound quality, but nothing to interfere much.
This novel doesn't move quickly. Rather, it luxuriates in the mind of the narrator for long stretches. There is very interesting story material here, but this is more of an intricately designed character sketch than a more traditionally arced novel.
That being said, though, it DESERVED the pulitzer. No question. Roth is a master of rendering psychology on the page.
Ron Silver the actor reads this wonderful book. His distinctive voice may take a few minutes to adjust to, but his new york accent is perfectly matched to the text. His rendering is masterful. I've not read the book but can't image this isn't one of those where the reader actually improves this Pulitzer winner.
I plan on reading everything I can by this author. American Pastoral has a very intersting story line, but what really struck me about this book is Roth's fantastic ability to "turn a phrase". I found myself rewinding and relistining not because I was confused by his writting but because I was entrawled by it.
Even some of the most terrific works of literature can come across as less than great if the narrator doesn't do the work justice. But Ron Silver has done a fantastic job narrating this lovely book. This is probably the kind of book I would not be able to get through were I reading it physically, but in audio book form, it is a true pleasure. Detailed descriptions and extensive dialogue that might otherwise seem tedious to the average reader, especially someone new to Roth's work, are a simply joy to take in thanks to Mr. Silver's dedicated 'performance." His accents are charming, and his speed varies according to the tempo of the scene which really helps. Of course, Roth is a wonderful writer, with or without a talented narrator and American Pastoral reminds me of "Middlesex" in both its extensive exploration of a single family's history, and the humor with which its characters are brought to life. Probably a book everyone... especially any potential fiction writers... should read.
Roth knows that a book is more than a plot. His charaters are real as the guy sitting next to you on the bus--and a heck of a lot more interesting. Ron Silver doesn't just read the book, he performs it.
Well worth the listen--especially for readers who remember the 60's.
I like books that have interesting characters and easy to follow plots. For example, Cormoran Strike, is a great character for me.
This book is one of the great American novels. How anyone could ever give this book one star is beyond my comprehension? Not only is the language gorgeous but the issues that Roth deals with are so deep and affect all of us. They are difficult issues about morality and child raising and guilt and work ethic. Every page dealt with things than any thinking moral person grapples with everyday. What thoughtful parent has not had the awful experience of their child doing acts for which we suffer? What thoughtful parent has not blamed themselves for the strange behavior of their child and searched their memories for some action that could have caused their children to turn out the way they did? If there are people who's children have not disappointed them in some way, they should count themselves having won the genetic lottery. One in a billion maybe. I think that people who couldn't finish reading this book did so because they are in denial about the problems that the Lulov's have gone through that they themselves have probably have experienced and they can't face the issues. The central theme of the book, that of the American ethic of: work hard, be a good person, follow the rules and good things will happen to you. This book portrays that life isn't fair and that terrible things happen to good people. The last line of the book is so profound: "What on earth is less reprehensible than the life of the Luvov's". This book is not for dummies who enjoy vampire, bloodsucking, inane characters. Each of the characters in this book are so thoroughly drawn, so complex, so filled with contradictions, that by its end, I thought I was a part of their lives. Contrary to some reviews that thought the book was too long, I thought it was too short. I craved to know more about all of these people. What happened to them? What happened to Merry after her confession? What happened to the Luvov's marriage? In addition, the reader was spectacular. I found myself so totally involved in both the internal conversations and character conversations that it was hard to determine reality from fiction. As a boy, I had heard conversations exactly like these from my Uncles and Parents. What was particularly eerie for me was that I grew up in Newark and Elizabeth and lived three blocks from where Mary grew up and went to the same high schools described in the book. Phillip Roth captured the precise moment in time and with the perfect tone of the time.
About 10 years ago my kids gave me an Audible account for my birthday. It was the best birthday present ever!
Ron Silver knows how to read. It was almost as if he was speaking his own words. I never got the feeling he was reading. His voice might take a bit of getting used to, but I enjoyed every minute.
The story depicts one family's tragic, up-close encounter with an important piece of American History. The use of repetition works to emphasize the character's confusion and regret as he scrambles to save his family from the devastating effects of tragedy. It is told as a story in a story. I think the story might have benefitted from being tied up a little more neatly at the end by the storyteller. But all in all, I do recommend this read.
This is a little out of my normal genre, but wow! This was well writen all the way around. Great well defined characters and a great storyline. Ron Silver had the perfect voice for the narration. In my top 30 out of 300+ listens. Listen and Enjoy!!